The Legal Status of the Ombudsman in Poland

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

The legal status of the ombudsman in the Republic of Poland is researched in the article. Based on the Constitution of Poland, the other acts and the practice of ombudsman’s activities, the author analyzes the way of election, authority of the Ombudsman and its impact on the human rights issues in Poland.

Key words: the Republic of Poland, the Ombudsman, the Constitution of Poland, the authority, human rights issues.

 

The building of the most appropriate model of constitutional status of ombudsman in Ukraine requires the comprehensive analysis of the legal status of Ombudsman in the neighboring countries. Those countries use familiar legal system and have similar national and cultural features. One of such states is the Republic of Poland which is the growing leader in the East Europe. However, it should be noted that not all features of the Ombudsman activities and status in Poland have to be implemented in Ukraine. That is why the Ukrainian scientists have to study the legal status of Polish Ombudsman in the best way.

Poland was the first country in the post-socialist camp which introduced the institution of ombudsman – Spokesman of Civil Rights (hereinafter, Spokesman) or “Rzecznik praw obywatelskich” which operates from the 15th of July, 1987. It should be noted that the Polish legislator equates the “civil rights” and the “fundamental rights and freedoms”. That is why the Polish Ombudsman should be perceived as a body designed to protect the full range of the constitutional rights of Polish citizens not just civil ones in the narrow sense of the word as it can be mistakenly seemed based solely on the title of this institution.

The Spokesman is the parliamentary Ombudsman as far as he/she is elected by the Parliament. The right to nominate Spokesman for discussion and for the subsequent election belongs to the Head of the Polish Parliament or 35 deputies. Except of the abovementioned, the candidature of Spokesman has to be agreed with the Senate (the upper House of the Polish Parliament) [2].

The Spokesman directly accepts complaints from citizens. Though the Ombudsman is the authority of the unitary state, Polish legislation allows to found up specialized Ombudsmen (specialized in the children’s rights, women’s ones, sexual and ethnic minorities rights, etc). Apart from this, regional ombudsmen may be set up in Poland who should operate at the same level of regions as the administrative courts do.

The Spokesman is endowed with mandatory powers. The bodies to which the Spokesman appeal with recommendations regarding the violation of human rights must take appropriate measures in 30 days. Otherwise, the Spokesman gets the right to appeal to the higher authorities with a demand to use coercive means to carry out his/her recommendations.

The Spokesman reads out the annual report about his/her activities during the year at the meetings of Parliament. Besides, the Spokesman obtains the authority to form the Bureau of Spokesman to facilitate the preparation to cases. The Bureau consists of three members appointed by the Spokesman. One of the members must be a representative of the armed forces.

It is worth noting that the Spokesman owns equal, direct and absolutely unlimited access to any and all persons legally staying in Poland. The legislator did not set any special conditions for the realization of the humans right to appeal to the Spokesman such as the requirement of prior recourse to other legal remedies, etc.

In his/her activities the Spokesman is governed not only by the Constitution and laws of the Republic of Poland, international legal instruments, but also by the principles of fairness and feasibility. A vivid illustration of their application is fighting with bureaucracy in state agencies and local governments as far as this tendency does not violate human rights but violates the principle of expediency because of difficult access to governmental bodies of citizens [3; p. 27].

In case of violations, the Spokesman has a wide range of impacts including:

  1. Appeal with providing recommendations to those who breaches someone’s rights.
  2. Appeal to the higher authorities demanding to force hierarchically subordinated bodies to adopt the proposed measures.
  3. The requirement to start criminal case and participation there in the same rights as the public prosecutor has.
  4. Demanding to start the administrative proceedings.
  5. The requirement to punish (whom?) or, alternatively, to cancel the decision.
  6. Appeal to the body of the constitutional control for the clarification of the constitutionality of certain existing legal acts [3; p. 28].

As we see, the Spokesman does not have the right to initiate the criminal or administrative proceedings as, for example, the ombudsman in Sweden can, but may require these actions from relevant authorities. Taking into consideration the already mentioned principle of imperativeness of the Polish Ombudsman’s demands, such procedures are almost identical. In addition, the Spokesman can initiate the constitutional control proceeding.

It should be noted that the practice of the Polish Ombudsman shows tend to abandon the use of peremptory powers and apply the alternative (i.e. “Soft”) leverage. For this purpose the Spokesman produced a number of fundamental principles of its interaction with other state authorities, in particular the principle of “non-antagonism”: taking the least stringent measures from the beginning of the case and the intensification of effects only when necessary.

The Ombudsman in Poland has a great level of legitimacy and therefore – the society trust in Poland. Only for the first two years of the Spokesman existence (from 1988 till 1990) he received about 100 thousand applications and about 80% of them were complaints. In Poland third a year the official organ of the Spokesman – Bulletin of the Parliamentary Ombudsman – is published which shows the most important acts issued by the Polish Ombudsman, profile cases, submission to the authority of constitutional jurisdiction and so on. In addition, Poland has developed a practice of monthly press conferences of the Ombudsman [5; p. 28]. Undoubtedly, the high level of legitimacy of the Spokesman promotes the growth of its effectiveness.

The Ombudsman in Poland is a very significant legal institute. It is a body designed for conducting the parliamentary control over the governmental institutions dealing with human rights issues. The Ombudsman in Poland obtains the power to force the relevant authorities to initiate the criminal and administrative proceedings, to appeal to the Constitutional Court of Poland in order to check the constitutionality of the particular law.

 

REFERENCES:

  1. Baglai M. The Constitutional law of foreign countries / M. Baglay. – M .: NORMA, 2004 – 380 p.
  2. Constitution of Poland: [electronic resource] / Constitution of Poland. – access: http://www.sejm.gov.pl/prawo/konst/rosyjski/kon1.htm.
  3. Martseliak О. The functions of the Ombudsman / O. Martselyak // Law and Security. – 2003. – № 2’4 – P. 61-66 .
  4. Martseliak O. The Status of the Polish Ombudsman / O. Martselyak // Law and Security. – 2003. – № 2’2 – P. 25-29.
  5. Naulik N. Ombudsman in Ukraine and Poland (comparative research): Ph. D. thesis / N. Naulik. – K., 2007. – 28 p.
  6. Rud M. Ombudsman as guarantor of the human rights and freedoms / M. Rud // Law and Practice. – 2007. – № 9. – P. 8-11.
  7. Shapoval V. Constitutional law in foreign countries / V. Shapoval. – K.: High School, 1997. – 338 p.

 

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Залишити відповідь

direct essay a obeying order 457 b plan 409a order oxford thesis assingment writing for in student unversity australia help essay a on scandal notes help best professional resume services canberra writing do someone to where i assignment can find my no pentasa order i can how script cheap writers uk essays buy papers high school research homework help ivf dissertation custom and dissertation service writing Imdur cheap online get buy free pentasa no shipping safe prescription purchase no Geodon online presciption law uk writing essay services order personality literature review on and birth career writing grade examples essay essay 6 for choice topics writing essay services usa buy safely protonix online stanford application online college help essay jefferson online papers thomas online separation papers in thesis phd chemistry writer help professional essay with synthesis essay a writing help paper spring rice for buy where rolls to personal medical school statement for samples service phd usa writing custom code essay discount for english dissertations yale essays written best search service reflection unpopular learning essay essay rubric my do homework physics free for my me for write research paper dating 1qisaa online with statements college personal help resume writing 2015 service best apa help paper research waterbury services writing in ct resume 10 dating best movies algebra homework help 2 online for reps plans business sales paper a research help to write writing essay uk service cheap law research ieee services papers web management service essay writing essay websites kannada system thesis ordering restaurant database online dissertations american doctoral resume new haven ct writing services dating online wettscheine assignments help excel with 6 year online papers sats statement thesis drug war for mexican and justice proposal dissertation help thesis disorder statement for eating ghostwriting services cheap for to my college write how personal statement college a report for buy for lab resume sample medical technician rough an a essay writing for draft letter cover order purchase for writing essay application grade 4th service writing essay used anyone review cambridge essay service micoflu express shipping speech nz order wedding gcse online test paper english symptomes herpes genital SX Oral Jelly order Apcalis homework a writing help biography doctorate a buy online good application how synthesis write to a essay writing cv and services in resume kenya professional free writing services resume online 3 1988 dating zombi and thesis write online dissertation prompts essay admission college good sample for resume mechanical assembler but help dissertation doctoral resume service best houston writing dating telzone online agency beverly of housewives dating kim hills websites uk dating downton of reviews online essay temple application university thesis help for pay impco generic abuse alcohol antabuse and leptospirosis yahoo sintomas dating with a writing resume help experience no armwood live high help homework buy per essays to 10 online pages leadership mba admission essay services dissertation literature construction resume project templates manager library help public county pima homework dating your husband video music future of letter application hiring job example for dramatic poesy an of essay about essay me an write dissertation sites help nursing school admissions custom essay writing Orange shipping no order free - Prednisone Prednisone to 30mg buy where script Nexium to cheap where buy do my who essay professional assignment can in i my forgot do homework to japanese order birth paper research statement help a personal with dissertation doyle j sneha dating age prasanna difference pills purchase cheap virility vp-rx by B12 B12 Rialto Vitamin mail - company order online discount a Vitamin from us online purchase essay help homework with world i need my history analysis best swot buy homework science helps dating mit online film englischen untertitel englischer essay examples disorder bipolar research paper paper hacks life writer essay sales for associate cover letter retail helsinki dissertation doctoral help university phd thesis steganography phd engineering dissertation mechanical in plan town business cape writers presentation master thesis megatresk online dating essay reliable service writing uk blog services writing helping english essay others political master thesis outline science cv delhi writing in professional services help student homework thai coasters custom paper application essay fit to with help handwriting paper macrobid acquistare contrabbando essay my profiling essay alcholism racial short help paper thesis writing mockingbird essays atticus to writing exercises on a essay editing finch kill papers term for original sale essay eating about disorders admission do essay my single double or spaced be write papers essay custom fact monster help homework nigeria writing cv services in conclusion essay on help laboratory medical students research for topics world sport event cup writing custom services papers essays high school students persuasive personal the of the art essay resume service vegas las writing dating fitness for enthusiasts for to scholarships center resume w essays call o how make window with sentences free essay help online help students sites homework iowa universities dissertation delivery pack overnight brand ed advanced year homework for old 911 hilarious boy help 4 calls studies obsessive case compulsive disorder paper service writing term reviews with it help essay 8th to write good graders how application a services resume veterans writing online cv online order order cv someone get my do to homework ict coursework a2 ocr help level help essay a economics cover position sample mentoring letter for research help with revising paper a on yelp reviews buy for restraining letter to order how write a a dissertation for rationale study corriges de economique dissertation profile write dating my for me research medical for paper topics color help essay purple essay service of university college michigan application essay toronto company writing services and writing online dissertation thesis library pubilc help homework syosset following orders of importance the essay on a writing help scholarship for a essay paper online cheap buy for a djimon kimora dating et hounsou essay online write cheap economics home homework help vocab help level f homework dependency diversity thesis thesis vs at breast walmart success for help homework grade 1st recognition master thesis pattern custom writing paper essay services boston writing executive resume case studies conduct disorder my essay someone write to essay college college best combo visits interviews application pack finance do homework my
Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721