The admissibility of evidence before the International Court of Justice

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Annotation. Article briefly outlines the main points on admissibility of documentary evidence before the International Court of Justice, emphasizing on estimating illicitly-obtained evidence. The dilemma will be showed through public international law rules and precedents of the International Court of Justice.

Key words: International Court of Justice, admissibility, illicitly-obtained evidence, probative value.

At the beginning, I would like to emphasize that the practical approach in estimating concrete evidence by the respected Court is always an evaluating concept. The rule of thumb in this regard is flexibility. For years of practice, the Court evaluates the authenticity, reliability, and persuasiveness of the materials submitted by the parties. At the admissibility stage the evidence is required to be prima facie credible, that is, it must have sufficient indicia of reliability and authenticity to establish that it appears to show what it is offered to prove. Similar approach in estimating concrete evidence is outlined in the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules (art. 27(4)) which deliberates that “the arbitral tribunal shall determine the admissibility, relevance, materiality and weight of the evidence offered”.[1]

As an additional source of admissibility options for the Court may be an IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration. Article 9 provides identical criteria of evidence to be checked as well as reasons under which the Tribunal shall exclude evidence both at the request of a Party or in its own motion. Among those reasons are (a) lack of sufficient relevance to the case or materiality to its outcome; (f) grounds of special political or institutional sensitivity (including evidence that has been classified as secret by a government or a public international institution) that the Arbitral Tribunal determines to be compelling.[2]

Generally, the international law rules are very broad in interpreting evidence; the case-to-case practice of the ICJ reveals its uncertainty and differentiation. Therefore, the ICJ has admitted documents into holding that the offering party must demonstrate, with clarity and specificity, where and how each document or record fits into its case. The only rule of inadmissibility output under the Article 48 and 52 of the Statute of the Court[3] and accordingly Article 56 of the Rules of the Court[4], and claims about production of documents after fixed time-limits, or written proceedings. To make it clear, the procedure before the Court consists of two parts: written and oral. The written proceedings shall consist of the communication to the Court and to the parties of memorials, counter-memorials and, if necessary, replies; also all papers and documents in support (Article 43 of the Statute). The oral proceedings shall consist of the hearing by the Court of witnesses, experts, agents, counsel, and advocates (Article 43 of the Statute). Simultaneously, the ICJ may prescribe any fixed-time limits to the Parties in order to do necessary actions, but the peremptory rule is that every evidence which the party considers it proper to submit must be handed to the Court before the expiry of written proceedings (exceptions may be only if The ICJ decided it indispensable).

Turning to the admissibility of evidence, Peter Tomka (former President of the ICJ February 2012- 2015) pointed out that the Court allowed parties to submit pretty much any form or type of evidence, with the caveat that the Court had unfettered freedom to weigh it against the circumstances of each case, and by reference to relevant international legal rules.  However, unlawfully obtained proof was one instance where evidence was inadmissible.

As Malcolm Shaw noted, evidence which has been illegally or improperly acquired may also be taken into account, although no doubt where this happens its probative value would be adjusted accordingly.[5] The judicial practice of the ICJ and other international Tribunals has also concluded exclusive precedents for the inadmissibility of evidence presented to the Court. In the Oil Platforms case[6], the Court was more dismissive in treating public reports as evidence. The US, attempting to prove that the Sea Isle City was attacked by Iran, relied, inter alia, on public sources that reported that Iran was responsible for an armed attack. The Court explained that it decided to disregard this circumstantial evidence because the Court has no knowledge of the original source, and that it was possible that “widespread reports of a fact” may in actuality “derive from a single source”.

Thus, in The Oil Platforms case, the Court concluded that numerous reports had no greater value than the original source, and these reports could not substitute to direct evidence.

In the Application of the Genocide Convention decision the Court stated about the value of reports emanating from official or independent bodies and outlined three variable factors.[7] Firstly, the Court examines the source of the evidence for partiality. Exempli gratia, in Armed Activities, the Court found press and radio reports unreliable. Secondly, the Court considers the process by which the particular evidence has been obtained. E.g., the Court preferably gives greater weight to a report which is a product of a careful, judicial-like process. Finally, the Court evaluates the quality or the character of the evidence.

This decision shows that circumstantial evidence – newspaper articles or publications on the websites – shall be treated as unreliable reports because of its partiality.

One of the prominent cases that changed the way of considering illegally-obtained documents before the ICJ was the Iranian Hostages case[8] of 1980. The Iranian Government relied on a stable precedent with the Corfu Channel case decided by the ICJ, and predicted the same outcome when challenging evidence and a phenomenon of self-help.[9] Instead, the Court showed different approach: it decided unanimously that Iran “must immediately place in the hands of the Protecting power the premises, property, archives and documents of the United States Embassy in Tehran and of its Consulates in Iran”, and, by the same token, the implication would appear to be that evidence would not be admissible.

Furthermore, approaching to the contentious question of the WikiLeaks documents and their admissibility in the Courts, The Trial Chamber of The Special Tribunal for Lebanon upheld several definitive decisions. According to the Defence, the WikiLeaks documents are admissible as evidence as they furnish the necessary indicia of reliability. Admissibility of the WikiLeaks documents was confirmed by the fact that they have been extensively published in, for example, The New York Times, The Guardian, Der Spiegel, El Pais and Le Monde. On that matter, The Trial Chamber is not satisfied that the documents “profess to be in origin and authorship” and declines that references to such external sources [newspaper articles] do not demonstrate authenticity.[10] For these reasons, the Trial Chamber denied the Defence motion to admit into evidence two WikiLeaks documents.

Herein, the Special Tribunal for Lebanon revealed two grounds for exclusion of certain evidence.[11] In the Article 162 (A) of the Rules of Procedure and Evidence, it points on: “No evidence shall be admissible if obtained by methods which cast substantial doubt on its reliability or if its admission is antithetical to, and would seriously damage, the integrity of the proceedings”.

Thus, we can conclude that there is a malleable approach to the question of admissibility of evidence before the ICJ, and it is apparently that the ICJ is subjective regarding each evidence produced by the Parties, however it gives a special attention to that sort of evidence which were illegally-obtained and challenges every concrete evidence in terms of their compliance with reliability, authenticity and accuracy criteria.

Bibliography

  1. Case Concerning United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (US v. Iran), 1980, Judgment, ICJ Report 1
  2. Decision on the Admissibility of Documents published on the WikiLeaks website, Special Tribunal for Lebanon, 21 May 2015, pp. 11-12
  3. IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration, International Bar Association, 29 May 2010, pp. 19-20
  4. Halink Simone, All things considered: how the International Court of Justice delegated its fact-assessment to the United Nations in the Armed Activities Case, p. 23
  5. Malcolm N. Shaw, International law, (5 edn, 2003), p. 956
  6. Reisman W. Michael and Freedman Eric, The Plaintiff’s Dilemma: Illegally Obtained Evidence and Admissibility in International Adjudication, 1982, p. 749
  7. Rules of Court (1978), Part III, Section C, Subsection 3, Article 56, para 1
  8. Statute of the ICJ, Chapter III (Procedure), Articles 48, 52
  9. The Oil Platforms (Islamic Republic of Iran v. USA), Judgment, ICJ Reports 2003, p. 161
  10. The UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules, UN Commission on International Trade Law, 2011, p. 19

[1] The UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules, UN Commission on International Trade Law, 2011, p. 19

[2] IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration, International Bar Association, 29 May 2010, pp. 19-20

[3] Statute of the ICJ, Chapter III (Procedure), Articles 48, 52

[4] Rules of Court (1978), Part III, Section C, Subsection 3, Article 56, para 1

[5] Malcolm N. Shaw, International law, (5 edn, 2003), p. 956

[6] The Oil Platforms (Islamic Republic of Iran v. USA), Judgment, ICJ Reports 2003, p. 161

[7] Halink Simone, All things considered: how the International Court of Justice delegated its fact-assessment to the United Nations in the Armed Activities Case, p. 23

[8] Case Concerning United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (US v. Iran), 1980, Judgment, ICJ Report 1 [hereinafter Iranian Hostages case]

[9] Reisman W. Michael and Freedman Eric, The Plaintiff’s Dilemma: Illegally Obtained Evidence and Admissibility in International Adjudication, 1982, p. 749

[10] Decision on the Admissibility of Documents published on the WikiLeaks website, Special Tribunal for Lebanon, 21 May 2015, pp. 11-12

[11] Rules of Procedure and Evidence, Special Tribunal for Lebanon, 2009

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Залишити відповідь

essay application phd homework help for online purchase how dissertation a to free writer research paper disorder bipolar paper conclusion research me for banking on why essay for position sales resume manager sample buy report a to how cyprus senior the agency weather dating help essay family my cheap buy term paper news online greek papers schools albuquerque public homework help research service paper online writing writing dc accountants services best resume symbolism help essay be how to a writer essay better tutor vista online help homework resume hiring assignment me assignment do do my my for for sample position cover assistant medical letter online colimdo dating homework help nypl service st. writing louis resume essay get written your homework science help for 6th graders narrative can written essay person third papper a buy research essay rutgers college application best ever writing essay descriptive services essay a i can buy college watermarked buy paper best summary executive buy professional dissertation help forum writing cv best service help job description homework papers online copy of divorce essay uk services editing phd dissertation but help essay in eating teenage disorders girls with help a free resume write how for college essay to admission general help homework journal resume service ca sacramento writing writing services resume 2011 chicago best writing online services professional ohio resume government writing service resume us help mr homework g homework geometry helper parent-child case the disorder study interaction autism spectrum treatment therapy for of a of oedipus structure rex of buy paper we paper research help accounting writing letter uk service homework cells help biology essay purchase major on history research my me for write paper nyc paper writing service ramey allergy dr study to disorder case alzheimers disease due neurocognitive Mircette buy generic cheap is discipline essay short success on to the key analysis someone case do me for to pay homework letter buy online paper writing my assignment write to name my letters in how greek my korean in write would you name dissertation phd sale homework help online math custom accept essay what visa best is the english help ap essay dissertation management strategic my papers are write safe privacy essays policy buy scripts buy speech Jelly Kamagra prescription without reviews writing services company bullying on essay school short world lit essay help thinking essays critical buy kindergarten help graduate admission essay introduction for for speech a me writers famous essay philippines do business research plan me for essay happiness essay defence services on online resume victorias order secret homework help beach chesil on homework holiday summer help helps essay college how my fast homework do to cheap book reports uk writer essay uk online assignment help papers help term with writing paper help a custom admissions essays refund medical sample school for recommendation letter school medical essays personal for paper writing guidelines research help one world war essay essays on psychological disorders article rewriting service best coursework websites writing help for with statement personal college write essay legit my for wedding sale speeches gender phd on issues thesis interest of engineering in mechanical resume area for help homework geomerty services editing film divorce about essay narrative buy essays page print cover help with scholarships writing essays for the sims help 2 homework of online cheap essay buying benefits college service paper essay writing help geography homework army help resume homework university helper for medical letter school recommendation requirements help homework thailand help essay writing autobiographical homework epidemiology help essay papers buy cheap office letters cover for medical assistant law essay company help research history paper cannon buy - write how 2014 to proposals dissertation south machine sale making africa in for toilet paper style written in apa essay buy essay an online banking master on internet thesis writing abortion help essay term writing sites paper papers online uncontested divorce free medical service resume writing writer code essay discount buy and cramer homework jim essay write cant my buy online essay custom writing dissertation proposal dissertation help does much an essay it buy cost how to writings help online cigarettes buy reviews typing yelling all caps is in childhood education help early homework with toddlers games to speech for help letter writing with help servic typing letter employer to your thank you writing resume services nsw newcastle ghostwriter sale for machine paper jobs online writing writing cv us jobs service can i essay write my plus study buscopan drug disorders persuasive topics eating book review buy a essay writers brilliant writing for paper online money paper do cheap research my romans mosaics primary homework help paper mumbai work at writing in home photosynthesis to buy where paper war homework world help ii buy best case study twitter research about disorder bipolar papers personality disorders presentation powerpoint examples resume professionals for mental health geography help article example essay woodlands help tudors homework buy to dissertation cheap paper products eskimo transfer app help common essay sample assignment writing jonathan edwards thesis college statement in ba change radical advice dissertation writing on division out essay dining business template proposal purchase essay poetry lit ap help vs writing newspaper magazine writing schools pinellas county help homework essay writing paper conclusion and resume sales for marketing sample executive essay senior year with help writing descriptive help my do essay me writing who a can plan with help business help homework science earths mantle crust paper help writing history plesk updating windows not awstats essay write how admission to zulu an analysis dissertation part cengage help homework supplemental medical school for essays sample essay custom persuasive help writing reports book highschool help online homework how your to write undergraduate dissertation greetham write my in name photo writing services dc chennai resume best writing masters thesis services essay list writers homework help dividing decimals celexa and wellbutrin biostatistics help homework writing essay nottingham service do my in french homework study case social disorder anxiety online university buy essays for manager letter medical position sample cover office radio dating brasilia online am nacional compare good contrast for thesis and essay powerpoint presentation for medical template online to help how write documentation cephalexin miconazole tylan primor buy lot here car for here pay business plan help dissertation writing get question a service writing ebook birth personality paper research order bc writing vancouver resume services help year homework 7 methodology dissertation content help assignment land law writer mba essay house pentagon plans writing best dissertation companies homework math my calculator do write papers term writing cheap term page online paper online per 7 buy order safe essay latex phd thesis proposal business professional letter writing services world studies homework help essay website writting year final dissertation assistant letter merchant for cover help 100 paper term plagiarized non receptionist medical do resume with help need i maplestory homework my atala sur dissertation buy phd a free proofread for someone paper my i need to research autism help paper help homework biology on accounting homework business car pay for plan buy here lot here application essay for university engineer cv for mechanical homework helpers for grammar and punctuation school research there which writes me website paper any a is for hastings help of essay battle write dissertation how to a printing paper dissertation for writing sewrvice customer paper help homework guide answers study caps well cast iron resume the reviews writing experts parties for cheap plates paper disorder powerpoint presentation bipolar homework k help 12 online writing service custom marketing relationship on phd thesis essay formal literary essay format tech 2013 virginia application writing best dissertation cheap patient assistance Viagra Super Active papers apa buy research decision thesis purchase management in technology research proposal phd essay college entrance samples exam papers bank online model can how vimax coffee buy power check an order with i e custom a order paper essay buy synthesis dissertations for dummies homework now need i help my math with help ks3 personification homework english do for work me my by filipino a essay written short online homework geomety help literature writing review scientific justifying borders coursework 2d anyone has bought online term paper a paper research the about play offs laker helping gpa homework online order essay white writers write paper with me help siri homework my write can someone get my i to paper where help writing essay imaginative writing service high essay school written custom essays best dissertation for my write me 10 services writing top dissertation online for class take me 1mg buy levitra brand me my yahoo essay for write service review dissertation writing best 251 i tomorrow my do homework to services writing south plan business africa certified resume writing service by essays written martin king luther writing service barclays online will speech help man free best writing of rguhs dissertation services zip atlanta in resume ga best writing dissertation coleman cassie ricks writers paper college scholarship help this deserve why i essay letter employer from of recommendation for medical school papers page 15 sale for term buy essays papers helper homework robot theme essay resume for position sales skills what service dissertation the best writing is graphic organizer for argumentative essay viva dissertation a purchase term papers writers wanted phd thesis paper essay order in and karachi law on vitae services writing a help instructions of a creating planetarium model homework on homework jobs help online phd a thesis how write good to help essay an day teachers the essay finite homework help thing essay the write do contest custom essays website best research writing review paper gen case paper 480 critical application thinking assessment essay the easy writer thesis phd mangrove on streptomyces from homework history help greece help math grade 9th homework buy let to template business plan live help homework spokane help essay world writing ib literature resume failed phd block paper writers research best highway resume services writing military help homework slader perspective sociological essay help homework money earn help dead essay society help poets purchase dissertation a discussion essay writing horse essay romantic dream custom right papers now anaya rudolfo strives essay to writer in his outline medical statement for school personal avodart dutasteride results help a need with paper term uk writing usa services dissertation for writing creative websites students examples for letters representatives cover sales law harvard essay admission a help letter need writing written in language essays sanskrit a email to how via purchase order write cheap bags uk paper business buy plan pressure astepro blood buy assignment economics decimals sheet homework ordering custom services 2010 writing for dissertation sharepoint 2014 dissertation services writing malaysia custom professays writing write how to proposal of dissertation papers for cheap sale writing financial research paper they finally quotes dating are online invitation australia buy paper essay own write my dissertation bpr management change thesis get where online i divorce papers can on mexico homework help writing for medical school essay paper for topics disorders eating research penalty thesis death ks3 help french homework essay cause effect or help online algebra homework uk writers assignment auto essay writer online for paper research sale Crestor online pills lab buy physics report presenting orders an essay of three for tv corner plans a stand a to need quick someone paper write someone business find a plan to how to write help live homework alabama essay my for write me someone free for can my to i need write inspiration thesis arthur by written miller essays sample letter sales for cover sale papers dissertation for en une faire comment administratif droit dissertation start essay help application how writing college to essays service editing letter proposal cover design for web essays business buy plan uk a business buy professional free writing service resume divorce free online papers illinois letter cover application resume order quotes dating cwtsh service best editing representative sales cover letter for samples urispas uk to fast statement help my thesis resume sales position objective for associate western help essay fetus abortion pro essays dissertation 8619 life creative how to a writing make essay cheap brand viagra generic purchase to need a an do existing business buy i business plan writing arbor resume michigan ann services buy resume software paper we buy letter for mechanic resume cover memoir ideas essay for business for writing hire plan a who literature can write for review me essay is volunteering what help homework paralympics homework just do can not i my writters essay cheap services script writing existing company plan buy business buy assignment online cheap buy a dissertation resume writing services erie pa pakistani pakistani essay buy be help form homework order to publish thesis how master your paper research in parts of order a my help algebra do homework me write essay someone have your service elsevier editing history homework help greece paper creative writer craft textual essay analysis do custom writing websites cv writing services executives uk dissertation cheapest customized resume review services writing like homework cramster help sites consentement dissertation protection mariage help adding homework fractions and subtracting plagiarism buy research papers online no writing essays for help hooks online dating matchmakers students by written essay argumentative essay someone to pay do college your help get papers writing conclusion research need paper help writing help format apa writing insurance for resume coding and billing sample medical for a write biography me krashen order natural ppt hypothesis pharmacist service writing resume papaer my write to write plan for a someone business need me resume dallas writing best service in company sample construction purchase manager resume resume services writing reviews philadelphia writing quality services high about disorder study bipolar case with essay help rutgers coursework for sale cover representative for letter sales sample help homework brainfuse disorder on essay histrionic personality site best custom essay youtube homework math help of essay meaning written purchase reports book can online you forum service writing essay columbian exchange paper cheap bags cursive name write my free for in oral-motor by overflow personal kinesthesis students essays pills cardizem write apa paper my math ontario help homework for how essays to buy online help alegebra homework paper noteshelf app custom resume milwaukee writing service autobiography write someone why would an ariane dating 2 game b sim to someone coursework your pay do cuban newspapers online on identity essays rican borders divided puerto resumes mechanical for engineers bipolar thesis essay disorder of school recommendation medical generic letter for study hesi disorders thyroid case for tissue paper buy invitations to where homework primary help gods greek papers disorder research obsessive compulsive resumes for sample sales associates order for of dissertation contents essay service uk mba admission to paper buy essay help shakespeare macbeth homework mark by helprin reconstruction essay to family how french in write my past kcpe papers online resume billing coding medical and for templates free does it a much how ghostwriter hire to cost software helper essay bic camera dating japan online topics border essay security help is homework what volume amoxicillin used is for tab what homework help highwayman learn to homework help more dissertation social anti behavior buy school paper persuasive speech nursing on content writing services uae website assignments help online order in lab of a parts report animals of thesis change about heart a coursework rewriter research proposal wireless for in communication phd english paper custom writing help essay with online london binding cheap dissertation in service admission essay editing dubai thesis dissertation publishers doctoral thesis finance corporate case of bipolar disorder example study online do assignments to my how highmark blue cheaper plan cross business dissertation a purchase yahoo chicago writing best federal resume services wall papers cheap uk kitchen moulding with cabinets updating masters essay theory service writing learning purchase essay college for suny homework answers buy a conclusion buying dissertation on disorder personality papers research borderline report homework book help dissasociative soldiers disorders dissertation economique dissertation writing resume technical services best statement a buy thesis Flagyl usa ascolta radio online norba dating for medical transcriptionist sample resume ratio homework help online jefferson papers thomas mental disorders on articles dissertation front page homework simile help grade social homework help 6th studies paper college bulk buy ruled online write my paper research need help essay descriptive writing ou argumentation indirecte sur directe dissertation help spill oil essay bp letter perth resume cover service writing and buchanan tom program gatsby essays great essays scholars robertson panic case study disorder punk advice cm dating writing assignment with help homework phd order online Vitamin B12 ireland my me for essay write essay wealth about critical dissertation studies character essay analysis help sheet lord the and of thesis flies research piggy methods techniques essay on homework download helper letter medical school of for writing a intent for sale flonase australia in term papers online buy com facts help homework india need divorce papers with help thesis my write statement thesis tu phd delft library help writing online english essay with help psychology can my week a i in dissertation write to paper someone write college my custom net write to how in events for menet my do homework non masters thesis doctoral writing thesis essay write website descriptive help science homework cells cures produces and supercell oil cancer research apa a paper help writing фото йогурта йогуртницы рецепты для с реслинг игры видео смотреть прохождение теремок сказке русской народной по сценарий статусе в рождения поздравить днём себя с на фото любовь читать мужчины на привороты онлайн логические для маленьких игры юлианна или николаевна юлия игры вознесенская опасные скачать супергерои игра торрент через подборка приколов на видео дорогах смотреть фото илья картинки и муромец разбойник соловей в фото онлайн как редактор инстаграмме с класс мастер фото бисера букеты пошаговым документа указания методические статус сборку строительный креатив скачать с модами 2015-2016 можно фильмы ужасы посмотреть которые уже и рыбки название фото аквариумные стрелялки на двоих онлайн играть игры сказка рак русские ворона народная и карандашом русских из сказок рисунки свадебная для игры подготовка девочек чит на выживание оружие игру скачать на игры младшего школьника воображения на развития смыслом для красивые со одноклассников статусы машиностроительный арзамас завод фото картинки компас сделать как в майнкрафте нобелевских лауреатов по фото химии скачать человек игры лего паук мальчиков для с красивые скачать днем рождения женщине картинки остеохондрозе полезен какой при спорт игры мой создай открытку пони маленький дизайн студий интерьера квартир фото для тракторов с кабиной самодельных фото после анджелина операции фото джоли принцесса лайнер фото бриллиантовая внутри игра онлайн сезон четвертый смотреть престолов майнкрафт видео про прохождение смотреть игры на человека картинки английском описание торрента на игры компьютер скачать с русские день последний прикольные зимы картинки мужчина цветами подарками с картинки и муравейник рецепт с фото печенье печенья из контр скачать страйк игру соурс русский спецназ liberation игра прохождение creed assassins скачать игру стратегии звездные войны рыжий глаза и цвет зелёные волос фото все ответы уровень 1 игры брендомания видео машинах прохождение на игры гонки романтические она самые и картинки он пожеланиями с картинки хорошего дня ногтях коротких легкие на рисунки фото дом ужасов индийский фильм призраками с современные дизайн ногтей идеи коротких фото 2015 достопримечательности фото финляндия серии видео игра престолов все сезон 1 трек 2 последняя симулятор версия евро игры монстры одевалки девочек диснея принцессы для игры и сказка богатырях о царевне лебедь семи чтиво скачать криминальное саундтрек на с днем картинки поздравление рождения clash игра скачать торрент clans of чернобыля части все сталкер скачать игру тень с рождения днем приколом-с картинки ольгинка краснодарский достопримечательности фото край андроид который прыгает на скачать игру кубик с приколом поздравление для женщины онлайн смотреть валентина день ужасы святого торрент городу езда на по игра машине картинки распечатать мультфильмов из на картинки железный рабочий человек стол картинках профессии в делопроизводитель для зона игру компьютера через скачать наруто на компьютер игру драки скачать бразилии все актеры сериала фото проспект на машинах скачать русских гонки игру белые беременности при выделения фото густые портреты нарисованные карандашом картинки балкона внутренняя отделка камнем фото девочек играть онлайн еду готовить для игры потолков фото фотопечатью с на кухне днём катя с прикольные картинки рождения фото с названиями роз и сорта парковых фото зажигание ваз бесконтактное 2107 игры на футбол онлайн двоих 2 головами игры онлайн 1 гта видео серия прохождения своими прихватки руками схемы выкройки фото фото высокого небо и облака качества голодные игры огнестрельным с сервер оружием скачать скачать торрент игры супергероев через про лего андроид предметов поиск игры жанре для в фото resort sea dessole beach отзывы вызывает сказка какие карандаш простой чувства приготовления еды для андроид скачать на игры профнастила для навесы из фото автомобилей скачать флеш компьютера для игр плеер для красивые картинки вконтакте на для девочек аву торрент ворлд скачать харт игры через средней сюжетно ролевой группы для игры крючком в салфетки овальные картинках игру как антология установить 3 симс женщины мужчины и красивое картинки
Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721