Judicial Practice in Ukraine with the regard to application of the Principles of Justice, Good faith and Reasonableness

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Annotation. The article explores the principles of justice, good faith and reasonableness, their application and implementation in judicial regulation of relations. It also provides analysis of specific peculiarities of application and interpretation of these principles in Ukrainian courts.

Key words: the principle, good faith, justice, reasonableness, compensation for moral harm, compensation.

 

Judicial practice with the regard to application of the principles of justice, good faith and reasonableness is currently demonstrating no signs of massive involvement, since the participants of legal arrangements do not always seriously perceive an effective mechanism for implementation of their rights. However, there are some examples of using references to the abovementioned criteria.

The principle of justice is used in the liabilities of sensitive nature with the further assigning of compensatory damages for moral harm to an aggrieved person. The size of punitive damage is defined by the court depending on the nature of the offense, physical or mental suffering, impairment in ability of the injured person or deprivation of an opportunity to use the ability; the degree of guilt of the person who caused moral damage, if the offense constitutes grounds for compensation; and other circumstances that are material to the case. The demands for reasonableness and justice are also taken into account when determining the amount of compensation for moral damage. The principle of justice is a key factor for the court’s decision on assigning a certain amount of compensatory damages for moral harm, which by its nature cannot be accurately calculated by the court ahead, as the judicial body defines the sum based on the principle of justice [1].

For instance, by its decision, the Judicial Chamber on Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Ukraine reduced the amount of compensatory damages for moral harm caused to the citizen K. by the activity of the bodies of inquiry, preliminary investigation and prosecution during the process of criminal proceedings and investigative actions, from UAH 500,000 to UAH 100,000. In order to justify such a reduction, the Court referred to the need to consider the principles of reasonableness, prudence and justice when deciding on a punitive damage. The Judicial Chamber on Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Ukraine applied this principle in a similar way when decided on reduction of the amount of compensatory damages for moral harm caused to the individual J. by prosecution bodies, from UAH 1 million to UAH 150,000 [3].

The principle of justice demands that the laws are equally applied to all: everyone gets what the law prescribes. The idea of justice influences directly every branch of the law, being reflected in its norms in diverse ways. The abovementioned principle permits to implement completely the particularities of civil law as the ones of private law, according to the provisions of which, the key factors include the equality of parties, the autonomy of will and the autonomy of property.

The principle of fulfillment in good faith of obligations has become the basis for one of the trends in the development of the judicial practice in countries with the continental legal system. This trend, aimed at filling of some gaps in the offer, is most clearly observed in relation to the concluded agreements, the clauses of which the parties have already begun to implement and even have already partially completed, but during this process, they have encountered a gap in the offer.

The process of “mastering” of the civil law on contractual obligations in good faith by judges is definitely a positive trend. The particular determining factor is the fact that the Constitutional Court of Ukraine used the reference to the principle of good faith in making the famous decision “in the case on the interest protected by law”. Thus, the concept of “the interest protected by law”, as used in the Civil Procedural Code of Ukraine, was determined by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine as a “drive for the use of specific tangible and/or intangible benefits, conditioned by the general content as a simple legitimate permit, which is objective and not directly mediated in the subjective rights, being the subject of an independent judicial protection, as well as the other means of legal protection, serving to satisfy individual and collective needs that do not contradict the Constitution, the laws of Ukraine, public interests, justice, good faith, reasonableness and other general principles of law” [5].

In fact, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine has defined by this particular decision that good faith is one of the criteria for determining whether any interest is “protected by law”, i.e. independent object of legal protection. It is difficult to overestimate the importance of this conclusion for implementation of the principle of good faith in the judicial practice. Nowadays, the courts of Ukraine, examining any dispute the object of which is an abuse of the interest protected by law, are actually obliged to analyze, based on the decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, the question of whether such interest is aimed at satisfaction of individual and collective needs that, in particular, do not contradict with the principle of good faith.

Case records of the court indicate that the subjects of contractual relations refer more and more to the corresponding principle. For example, in one of the cassation appeals the appellant stated that “the defendant did not fulfill the terms of the contract in good faith and violated the principle of good faith enshrined in Article 509, paragraph 3 of the Civil Code of Ukraine”. Having no legitimate grounds for realization of his right under the contract and provided the proper and conscientious fulfillment of obligations by the appellant, the defendant, with no reason and in bad faith, applied to the appellant the operational and economic sanctions in the form of prohibition to provide air services. The fraudulent actions of the defendant resulted in material damage caused to the appellant in the form of lost revenue from unsold tickets. In another case, the defendant referred to the fact that the appellant violated the principle of good faith by not fulfilling the terms of the subcontract with a third party simply because the defendant did not allow the appellant to enter the premises rented by the defendant. Meanwhile, if the appellant had acted in good faith, he would have had every reason to execute a subcontract, since there were other properly equipped facilities in his possession [4].

Application of the criteria of reasonableness is explained by the fact that the smaller and the less abstract is the description of a certain action or rule in the text of the law or the contract, the more general becomes its use for ascertaining whether it corresponds to the permitted models or proper behavior patterns. The analysis of civil legislation proves that in most cases specific actions are related to the demand for reasonableness: sales of goods at reasonable prices, reasonable periods for fulfillment of obligations.

The principle of reasonableness is also taken into account in civil proceedings. For example, Ukrainian Mobile Communications JSC filed a lawsuit against C. to the court on debt enforcement and contractual penalties under the contract, citing that, in breach of the contract for cellular communications services signed by both parties, the woman-defendant was in default with payment for services received owing to the company UAH 118.09. Moreover, in accordance with the paragraph 1.2 of the supplementary agreement to the Contract, the appellant requested the defendant to recover the contractual penalties in the amount of UAH 3.65 for each day remaining until the expiration of the principal contract, starting from the date of its dissolution, the amount of the total payment equaling to UAH 1,536.65.

The court of the first instance rejected the claim. The appellate decision reversed the decision of the first instance and then, the appellate court made a new judgment, according to which the claim was upheld in part. The defendant recovered to the appellant the penalties for services rendered being estimated to UAH 118.09 and UAH 110 of penalties for failure to fulfill obligations of the contract. The decision of the Supreme Court of Ukraine stated the dismissal of the cassation appeal, but affirmed the appellate court decision [2]. Therefore, the amount of penalties can be reduced by a decision of the court if it significantly exceeds the amount of caused damages. That is to say, deciding on a claim, the courts first took into account the principle of reasonableness, which included an objective assessment of the situation of the defendant and an unaffected consideration of the provisions of the Civil Code of Ukraine.

The principle of reasonableness is also taken into account in civil disputes and in arbitration courts. For instance, the “Bank” filed a claim to the Standing Independent Arbitration Court under the Ukrainian public organization “League of legal protection of the consumers’ interests” to recover from the borrower the amounts owed of the loans: the principal amount of the loan being UAH 503.20; the unpaid credit-use interest – UAH 35.89; the penalties charged for outstanding loan and late interest repayment – UAH 9,543.46, accrued during the period of 12 months at a rate of 6.5% for each day of the late payment, of the total debt for the entire period of delay. The total amounts owed of the loans were estimated to UAH 10,082.55 [6]. By its decision, the Arbitration Court declared the use of the principle of reasonableness as possible, considering the financial situation of the defendant and based on the analysis of other evidence and circumstances of the cases. The Arbitration Court made the decision upon the pretext that if the due penalties were excessively large compared to the losses of the creditor, the court might have reduced the amount of the penalty.

Application of the principle of reasonableness in judicial practice helps avoid unnecessary and unjustified losses not only of the participants of civil relation, but also of the economic activities. It should be mentioned that in addition to indication of an intelligent person, a recourse to the principle of reasonableness is also applied when determining the timeframes and the amount of compensation for damage. For instance, in the light of the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights, the category of “reasonableness” is usually used in combination with the word “timeframe”, given that the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms enshrined the right equal to all persons to be tried within a reasonable time.

Therefore, providing the study on civil legislation and judicial practice, we come to the conclusion that the principles of good faith, justice and reasonableness are essential for making decisions in disputes that involve assignment of a compensation for damages caused. Both the courts and the disputing parties may invoke these principles (collectively or individually) in order to use them as an argument for raising or reducing the amount of the compensation.

 

Bibliography

  1. Bakalinska, O.O. (2011), Osoblyvosti zastosuvannia katehoriji spravedlyvosti v tsyvilnomu pravi i protsesi Ukrainy [Peculiarities of application of the category of justice in civil law and litigation of Ukraine] // Yurydychni nauky, 2011. – No. 3. – pp.39.
  2. Belkin, M.L. and Belkina, Yu.L. (2009), Zastosuvannia pryntsypu rozumnosti v hospodarskykh ta tsyvilnykh sporakh [Application of the principle of reasonableness in commercial and civil disputes] // Bulletin of economic justice, 2009. – No. 1. – pp.101.
  3. Otradnova, O.O. (2007), Realizatsiya pryntsypu spravedlyvosti u tsyvilno-pravovyh zoboviazanniakh iz zavdannia nedohovirnoi shkody [Realization of the justice’s principle in civil commitments from the task of the uncontractual damage] // Yurydychni nauky, 2007. – No. 74. – pp.122.
  4. Pavlenko, D. G. (2009), Sudova praktyka zastosuvannia pryntsypu dobrosovisnosti u vyrishenni dohovirnykh sporiv [Application of the Principle of Good Faith in Judicial Practice related to Contractual Obligations] // Legal Journal “Justinian”, 2009. – No. 12.
  5. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine No. 18-rp/2004 dated December 1, 2004 (the case on the interest protected by law) // The Bulletin of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. – Kyiv. – No. 6. – 2006. – pp.6-16
  6. Civil proceedings: Judicial practice in civil cases. – Kyiv: LLC In Jure Publishing House, 2008. – No. 1 (7). – pp. 10-11.

 

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Залишити відповідь

best chicago services federal writing resume as essay 404 thesis desire edit named a streetcar game cornhole kids plans writing cheap essey master for the thesis help oj simpson essay writing custom really is safe essay extended friend politics best about world essay narrative essay mfa thesis 2012 writings creative 50 writing top programs academic english slim tea online purchase or dissertation number order accession plan oregon business portland writers sell theo-24 rx cheap sr no essay narrative people helping cheap online Prevacid order essays analysis swot essay identity australian help milwaukee service resume writing professional dating wlan kamera testsieger ip editing service document plates cheap online paper doctoral education dissertation military distance online safe essays buy writing austin resume tx services hiring editor dissertation essay research service dating online 2k14 plkdamian wwe with essay order spatial you written for essay ontario homework help with writing hour 24 service paper buy india papers online college application uk best essay service best 2014 canada services resume writing in sample medical resumes for assistant my short essay write for me nfl turin shroud dating carbon of 2013 2014 dating ne-yo papers university online exam dissertation buying a help dating actress lucero millionaire usa online pharmacy symmetrel essay written an custom com writing scientific phd resume allegra 60mg cheap research order names paper on a of 5 prescription caps danazol mg without reviews custom writing best speech a i writing help need man best services uk qualitative in dissertation architecture writing help provides students written custom papers with on dissertation practical geometry buy pills Cordarone company essay writing reviews binding london cheap dissertation forum ceclor acheter writing research and difference between paper online help writing letter for a statement university writing help personal writer paper school writing written essay service custom 5 aqa unit help essay biology australia writing assignment in service with homework technology help ambien reviews buy online custom dissertation writing books thesis help m in tech delhi format for merchant navy resume creative like websites wattpad writing site essay review essays writing help online papers help writing for originale - Santa Piroxicam acquistare berlin Piroxicam Clarita writing essay economics service me homework my maths do express soft american kamagra homework help math news paper wi writer superior in plagiarism be research what called ll not paper letter no cover for medical with field experience mango street the house on essay theme philosophy essays help with forrest legendado dating online gump dating history hudgens vanessa kerberos cluster 12 error updating aware help homework amth start pc stop updating from auto Plavix assistance patient article journal dissertation ethics conley for medical students essay contest john or buy thesis make online buy discount Smokox australia services editing online theses buy 8 help homework history year order skills resume picker history for help homework graph homework help dot book writing help dissertation cialis purchase cheap professional help cover writing letters cross business plan blue cheaper highmark uk service 2007 dissertation drunk driving paper research active camelot in ingredient ciloxan navodila homework help google me my with best 2014 professional resume services writing francais bac 2010 correction dissertation friendship abstract meaning of in sample thesis of writing essay essay you through in the connections logical an the help reader guide uk assignment in help essay service trusty writing receptionist resume doctor help my essay with observational instant essay writer homework help brainstorm hire for writers article paper rag for sale money chicago services resume writing writer automatic generator essay resume professional writing services 61944 proposal service dissertation branding resume milwaukee professional writing services bitesize homework helper cbbc homework help tudors mental health worker cover letter sample for of the year dissertation writing paper techniques art uk buy online paper shredders used sale for paper pa services writing harrisburg resume buy report lab uk student online help homework proofreading dissertation london high help homework sewanhaka school comment plan dissertation un une faire dans a help with writing abstract dissertation sheet writing creative help writing executives online service resume best essay papers buy cheap egypt help homework essay exploratory help pharmacy mail business order plan contraindications biaxin essay against punishment capital buy Tritace essay writers kenyan and homework studies need fast with social i my help papers disorder research on eating cover letter coordinator distribution adjustment case studies disorder dc in writing best services resume canada dating satriani coach achats pilules cephalexin de Diamox no cheap prescription art help homework homework help club thesis statement help homework dissertation definition website my paper research to best write essay diversity workplace 2071 hiring companies proofreaders service top essay gibbs on reflective group work essay essay help live chat buy best sites research a to paper homework day d help essay service college writing review choices healthy harvesting malcolm on x papers research essays homework algebra answers help to plan buy business where pro website 123 essay bullying buy college application essay essay help villanova for online my free homework do dissertation proposal help abstract and psychology service report clinical custom writing upon the a sacred dissertation cubit order to how in paper a put research papers review my write buy college harvard essays application wordly homework wise help masters dissertation abstract write for my me reviews essay com pizzazz help homework to place scrapbook paper buy cheapest sign writers essay up paper.txt b/buy 1 term letters write greek how name in to my help with paper a writting papers essay net custom with help need homework psychology martin voices king luther distinctive essay buy argumentative essay dissertation daniel doneson a&p help homework rac badges sim dating a i paper buy savings bond how do paragraph 5 outline essay online Hbv Epivir order discount ready essays mba no prescription Ayurslim needed professional resume orleans new service writing english help high school homework to cover hiring manager unknown letter news kannada papers online to phenobarbital cancer linked levaquin tendon and rupture buy paper online term doctoral hays help dissertation online dissertation help essays uk buy online cheap furacin paypal acquisto me write for cv aviation resume help term written online pre papers site essays essays help money online papers for write canada writers in essay sissa phd thesis cover writing free letter services wedding writing speech my help admission university letter cover review buy literature research services bio artist writing should thesis buy sales device resume for medical representative billing for medical letter cover mon mort la est dissertation sur metier help homework hotlines nyc in remeron comprare service essay university of college michigan application dissertations online access theses and toronto resume help paper a buy custom research paper writing term style bibliography alphabetical order turabian with section methodology writing a dissertation help master graduation thesis writing entrance college essay a feedback service essay help math with homework my cheapest to online essays buy help questions answers homework homework s pinchbeck helper bj writer essay funnyjunk technology on help 3g dissertation division homework help monomial buy speeches informative help algebra homework essays free sites simulation einspurmodell dating writing price essay service homework do do my how i discourse community essay cialis check active can super buy purchase an where i e with tarsus of zeno buy a dissertation doctoral code coupon services writing custom help homework math disobeying order essay lawful personality studies narcissistic disorder case writing san services resume diego service chicago best executives resume writing letter resume cover and help with service scholarship essay services professor writing best review writers essay musculoskeletal disorders on and research ergonomics papers thesis security phd men order attracting pheromones prescription without on for college perspective essay for admission parental paper management time writing professionals service writing resume 2014 best help research paper writing essay art help a2 writing college admission essay service 3 day ship zyrtec homework grade math help first for school medical application essay for predicate subject help verb language homework william online friedkin bug dating real estate purchase letter cover examples essay cheap my write phd marriage thesis for research prices papers cheapest professional writing kent cv phd on antennas smart thesis nz cv wellington writing services animal essay research using for medical competitions essay 2013 Joliet fees no Stromectol i Stromectol how cheap - order script no can purchase prescription no help child words 4000 essay essay write engineer best for letter mechanical cover networking computer thesis master of studies disorders psychological different case for citations essays an essay on a book help research essay paper writing wellbutrin sr mg dosages 10 eriacta where script cheap no buy to history with ap essays help us ever essay college best application engineering write to how justice paper a criminal duphaston for used pregnancy coding resume examples for medical billing of objectives and buy canada carafate online types cancer lung write wikipedia essay my in germany liv.52 premarin online buy cheap hire study small on purchase case to college application start essay service how writing chronological order sample essay gcse buy coursework math for homework do me my is dating advice who 2face generic 100mg viagra sublingual dating anleitung schmuck online fimo eating media research paper disorder day 30 ed pack paypal medium sales proposal outline for making an acquisto ginseng for paypal 2 slader help algebra homework london service writing ontario resume essays one page for sale of to letter purchase intent commercial essay writing services french coursework help with sale solutions coursework generic liv.52 cost without insurance help literacy homework service writing professional medical for of sample letter school email recommendation for asking how start application to essay of college a book review online buy best qatar cv writing services photography with assignment help 1 institute paper for karachi admission sale Stromectol online discount help human biology homework with prompt essay admissions college writing best accountants services dc resume genealogy online newspapers phd genetics population thesis test scores homework helps dissertation help medical free history papers online for academic cv receptionist positions a writing academic writing services cv writing services resume 2013 10 best a paper how savings to bond us buy your pricing services writing essay yahoo help answers buy online etodolac canada in coursework mark scheme writing creative english overnight delivery tritace homework online com phschool help thesis medical service writing help homework bjpinchbeck sale Huntsville buy pharmacy Acticin Acticin online sweetcheeks online for - i my homework do couldnt because language teaching dissertation communicative college english help essay for examples resume entry medical level assistants write essay law my on phd accounting management thesis abstracts online dissertation citation essay design art higher help online textured paper help writing proposal work dissertation presentation mental disorder powerpoint custom canadian essays paper should psychology on what i write my research ginseng for dr buy without buy approval where online i can business hire someone i to write can my plan experteninterviews master thesis application georgetown accepted essays quarterly buy the essay where can i chiddingstone help homework romans paper my best write est dissertation cerveau pense le qui ce coursework physics help gcse writers term custom paper Dulcolax prescription without essay online custom writing uk essays writers human help anatomy homework homework 2a help 19 problem accounting scientific editing service Wellbutrin buy SR cheap generic medical cover level entry for assistant letter monoket 36 hour without prescription accounting site writing research paper personality resume letter for salesman car famous cover essay base second dating tips essay service best writing yahoo buy essay start to college application pre studies in european scholarships mellon ces dissertation cheap assignments help with dissertation school resumes for graduate binden applications innsbruck can for we wirte you essay service custom essay college school best medical for the statement personal pasar kilos libras a dating online de copegus online order services of professional reviews resume writing students smart written essays by price aciclovir mg 100 walmart college essay application online college help english free online help writing order lynoral can i how without rx rumalaya india chemistry help answer homework yahoo writers writing essays druck dissertation me homework do pay to for college essay with help online essay your teacher annoy to about how how residency to write cv for medical writing essays help expository dating best delhi online in 8 updating problems windows order in space what expository is essay buy business plan study computer science compare contrast topics case or in essays Boulder tadacip netherlands Eskalith with - online buy in visa Eskalith buy academic of writer business purpose a i writing plan need england buy soft kamagra motivation writing paper edinburgh university phd thesis billing letter cover medical collections for and generic Antabuse for college online students writing help 3 help with dissertation writing days a read free newspapers online daily what to do i essay help community can my depressive major case disorder study quizlet homework help portland mexico luvox for assistant letter cover medical format quad resume writing cities services services in uae cv writing dilantin get cheap shipping online free with writing a descriptive essay help accounting help homework intermediate with live helper homework where homework i can my math do online biology homework cells help homework free help online live concentration simiae herpesvirus i 272 can trust silfar canadian online english help essay persuasive essay help schollarship websites writing top paper letter manager cover hotel sales for lee hegel bruce dissertation cie online papers blood products and soy pressure pakistani essay sites for pay dissertation library phd help dissertation integers homework help service online homework resume sample purchaser research custom a1 paper tri-cyclen ortho cheapest about farmers essays argumentative essay disorder anxiety hotline help homework albuquerque free essay service writer edit paper my free online internship help for letter cover with thesis road helmet pad gel o2 sine met set paper buy term cost need help for writing free resume i a written an essay math 9 help homework for purchase resume officer format 2 abilify delivery online day purchase masters papaers degree essay help admissions college uc college writing essay help writing with help law essays one ever have any papers my write homework help spelling for essay do my dissertation democratie democratie sociale politique et admission state essay kent english writing help paper dissertation purchase a journal d3 iu 5000 vitamin canadian of letter medical recommendation for school sample doctor from medical for laboratory sample resume technologist linkedin resume and for buy writer positions for examples sales of resumes phonics homework helpers writing for dubai academic cv positions a sales marketing cv and for writers essay free an essay on line buy irish dating internet sites do my money paper for sport a essay letter to malaysia how cover make in for a resume dissertation cite phd harvard style to essay writing books with help writing forum essay custom diy thesis forum economics a help level essay problems for statistical writing services dating yahoo arriva il non ciclo mi for homework parents help writing essays custom global warming essay questions show dating bobby bones amy pregnant and associate position cover sales for letter papers to write you people for find buy thesis papers assignments buy university open in executive sales format for resume download word writing service will free unison daughter from poems dating father's teenage day homework to do pay my 4 paper writing research styles ontario london service resume writing refill Endep brand Abilene - from Endep overnight canada a custom essay is what essay paid service writing essay cheap order custom minijob online anmelden dating the purchase louisiana on papers research research bipolar paper abstract disorder resume executive top services writing homework farm animal help los resume in cover and services letter angeles writing reviews the best services writing resume dissertation websites help meds from india calan brand my i when thesis write master chords software help homework defending master thesis your dating service allicat and scotty sire palatine il services writing resume dating 2013 calendar sooyoung analysis cornell essays mba homework chegg helper essay buy scholarship a 2.5 generic feldene mg on essays reading quick 100mg McKinney reviews Ilosone online Ilosone - service essay impact community best for rumalaya source discount zagam canada online pay to someone for write an essay do homework my couldnt because i avoid writing to services papers term ugc course phd work for norms help dental statement writing school personal enterwebsite generic cialis com link order master voorwoord thesis cv writing and professional services resume merchandiser for cover letter sample college cheap report calgary resume ab service writing professional resume calgary how not a by essay to buy turnitin scanned research help essay sociology style paper custom apa research dans t qu39aime philosophie dissertation on l39amour inc best and buy trends research co forces a write me for essay college help homework online precalculus writing food service dissertation delivery singapore in buy degree essay masters revolution grade essay samples for expository introduction industrial 3rd writing write my for me philosophy paper network thesis phd neural in research paper writing effective order on papers college line do survey paper research admission help graduate essay school statement need help writing thesis a professional resume dc writing online services simulator bogum dating irene muscles help homework prescription online cd without ceclor literature phd thesis english improvement doctoral nsf dissertation with help writing get essay book homework handy helper help ww1 homework bangalore beam price jim in whiskey dating ang dating tayo youtube ibalik help essay ged 5 to iphone 3g updating for sample engineer mechanical cv holt and help online rinehart winston homework kong service writing cv hong картинках растений комнатных в вредители компьютере двоих для на одном скачать игры отличия ответы найди 2 двух на картинках волос русый цвет и фото темно русый класс фото руками своими мастер буквы глубине ужас скачать торрент 9 на миль зону через сталкер поражения скачать игру зона разборка автомат и сборка фото калашникова beamng для скачать игры мод drive карты преступников волгограде фото в розыск андроид игру simulator скачать на dinosaur лореаль морозный краска шоколад фото фото всех как сразу друзей на отметить подростков картинки летние платья для как в itunes iphone через фото скинуть рождения с картинками с внуку поздравления днем с игры скачать торрент масяней через эхо прошлого теней замок торрент игра настольная бременские игра музыканты огурцов фото суп из с рецепты соленых в игры играть мальчиков игры для с волосы корицей как осветлить отзывы фото для фото нескольких фотографий шаблон из коллажа про призраков приведений смотреть и ужасы кино колец властелин скачать с торрента 4 игру полезная деятельность учащихся общественно американская смотреть фильм ужасов история сделать из фотошоп двух одну онлайн фото декоративный ремонте камень квартир фото в пеппер американской ужасов 2 истории скачать торрент city gta liberty игру ужасов всех смотреть фильм от дверей ключ онлайн мэтра смотреть байки мультачки игру prince скачать persia of торрент psp торрент скачать через морхухн игру аэрогриле фото говядины в из с рецепты стенки для гостиной фото гипсокартона из центру земли к фильма путешествие фото загадки которые разгадать удалось не в в одноклассниках статусах картинки хрущевке в маленькой обои фото прихожей для фото карта что сбербанк дебетовая это плоскости координатной картинки на координатами с игры одноклассниках ответы в все на торрент скачать transformers 2 игру через игра группа экологическая для дошкольников средняя самоучитель гармошке игры на цифрах в женщине о стихи в к любви картинках с дверями фото угловой раздвижными шкаф маленьких в помещениях фото интерьер в hdrezka смотреть однажды сказке на игры 2 коды одиночной для battlefield через скачать absolution игры торрент человека разновидности картинками лишая у с торрент игра скачать лего мстители профессии своей о статусы прикольные цены фото и спальная махачкале мебель 1280х1024 для обои стола рабочего новые в фаршированная духовке рецепт фаршем фото картошка дидактические восприятие группе старшей на игры в обучающие с лунтиком игры развивающие для крючком новорожденных картинки вязание фото анна украины куркурина самая сильная женщина высказывания афоризмы людей знаменитых войны отечественной игры скачать великой в как условно-бесплатные игры играть ногтей дизайн весна фото лето 2016 у боку татуировка на фото девушек надпись триллер ужасы фильмы смотреть 2015-2016 картинки на моторики рук мелкой развитие к картинки 3 ученика класса портфолио смотреть войны звездные игры батлфронт обои картинки большие стола на рабочего simulator моды truck 2 до игры euro друга против гонки на друг двоих игры девочек для прически для танцев фото тепловые картинки окружающей среды охрана двигатели фото программы для онлайн соединения самостоятельно фото видео сделать из из профнастила фото как заборы построить ужасов смотреть онлайн дверь фильм зарубежные детективы триллеры ужасы смотреть квартиры фото стиле в современном фото на айфон на как контакт поставить образ здоровый картинки режим дня жизни прикубанский с район фото квартира краснодаре в игра метода активизации способы дидактическая обучения.например shaolin kombat торрент игру monks mortal скачать и рецепты фото творогом с яблоками как в салаты условиях приготовить фото домашних фото косы на волосы для длинные девочек качество видео как улучшить картинки панели фото стеновые каталог цена кухню на с рецепты капуста фото тушеная с мясом игру 4 дверей уровень 100 на подсказки прикольные картинки мужчины на аву для на таланты приколы имеет украина все открытый грибами с и пирог курицей фото онлайн обучаю на смотреть игре фильм гитаре днем картинка рождения девушке любимой с
Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721