Terms of applying to the European Court of Human Rights

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Досліджено умови, яких відповідно до Європейської Конвенції з прав людини та основних свобод, потрібно дотримуватись при зверненні до Європейського суду з прав людини. При вивченні цього питання було проаналізовано відповідну практику Європейського суду.

Ключові слова: ЄСПЛ, умови звернення, Європейська Конвенція з прав людини.

We researched conditions under which person can apply to the European Court of Human Rights. We analyzed an appropriate law practice of the European Court.

Keywords: ECHR, terms of applying, the European Convention on Human Rights.

The question of the rights and freedoms of man is the most important issue of internal and foreign policy of all countries today. After the accession of Ukraine to the Council of Europe in 1995, and especially after the ratification of the European Convention on Human Rights, citizens of Ukraine have the opportunity to appeal to the Strasbourg court.

Analysis of recent research presented by scientists such as V. Kapustynskyy, N. Pronyuk, N. Sevostyanova, A. Kirichuk and others.

Problem: explore terms of applying to the European Court of Human Rights.

The main material research. European Court of Human Rights is an international body that consider applications submitted by persons who complain about violation of their rights set out in the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. This Convention is an international treaty under which the majority of European countries are obliged comply with specified basic human rights.

According to article 34 of the Convention: «The Court may receive applications from any person, nongovernmental organization or group of individuals claiming to be the victim of a violation by one of the High Contracting Parties of the rights set forth in the Convention or the protocols thereto». It means that a person may apply to the Court if he or she is personally and directly a victim of a violation by one of the states of one or more fundamental rights.

The Court may consider only those applications that are directed against States which have ratified the Convention or relevant protocols and concerning events occurring after the date of its ratification. The person may only appeal behavior (decision, action, inaction) of state and its agencies, institutions, organizations, officials or other government entities, local authorities. Citizens can appeal decisions, actions or omissions of state represented as one or several of these subjects [1].

Violation of the right should occur on the territory under the jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice. Only the person whose right has been violated could apply to the Court.

According to article 35 the Court accepts the application for consideration only after it been used all local remedies, and only within six months from the date of the final decision. The court does not consider application if:

  1. it is anonymous; or
  2. b) it is substantially the same as a matter that has already been examined by the Court or has been submitted to another procedure of international investigation or settlement and does not contain relevant new information.

Court declares inadmissible any individual application submitted under article 34 if it considers that:

  1. the application is incompatible with the Convention or the Protocols thereto, manifestly unreasonable or an abuse of the right of application; or
  2. the applicant did not suffer significant harm unless respect for human rights in the Convention and its Protocols, requires consideration of the merits and provided that on this basis can not be rejected, no matter which national court not considered properly [2, 59].

Exhaustion of local remedies includes the compulsory use of administrative and judicial tools stipulated in national legislation. However this condition is temporary. The Court may return to proceedings if the applicant fulfilled the condition of exhaustion of local remedies.

Today in Ukraine, the exhaustion of effective remedies in civil and criminal cases is appeal to the cassation instance (decision of inadmissibility for Arkhipov v. Ukraine, no.25660 / 02 and Vorobyeva v. Ukraine, no.27517 / 02). In economic cases such exhaustion is considered to be an appeal in cassation to the Supreme Court of Ukraine (decision of inadmissibility of the case MPP Golub v. Ukraine, no. 6778/05). In administrative cases exhaustion is appeal to the Supreme Administrative Court of Ukraine (decision of inadmissibility of the case Karuna v. Ukraine, no. 43788/05).

There is the possibility to appeal directly to the European Court in the case in the judicial practice of the highest judicial bodies is to clarify that deprive his chances to win the case, or when unfavorable position of the courts clearly known, as other persons or legal entities who found themselves in the same position certainly received a refusal. It is important to mention that ECHR established the absence of effective remedies at national level in certain categories of cases. It includes cases of excessive length of proceedings (judgment of Merit v. Ukraine, no. 66561/01), on conditions of detention (judgment Dvoynykh v. Ukraine, no. 72277/01), submitted a complaint or the claim of the State Executive Service of Ukraine (judgment Voytenko v. Ukraine, no. 18966/02) [3].

According to the article 35 applicants are required to apply an application to the Commission within six months from the date on which the final decision was taken. This provision, which is a restriction on the right to file an application requires a narrow interpretation. Simple message (letter) from the applicant is seen as «application», when the circumstances of the application is sufficiently clear.

The countdown of six months begins not only from the date of the national decision, but also the date when the applicant have knew solution and thus he was able to apply to the Court.

In cases when you can not appeal the decision or action state agencies, the term begins with the entry into force of the final decision or action. There is no «starting point» from which starts six months if the application refers to the enforcement of the law, the consequence of which is a violation that continues for a long time [4].

Rules of consideration anonymous complaints and appeals that contain new information (paragraphs 2 and 3. 35). When the application contains a matter that has been considered by the Court or has already been submitted to another procedure of international investigation or settlement court may accept it if it contains relevant new information. The application should not have previously considered by the European Court and similar international institutions – the Human Rights Committee, the Committee against Torture, the Committee against discrimination against women and so on.

In accordance with article 35 of Convention the Court must recognize application inadmissible if it is «incompatible with the Convention or the Protocols thereto, manifestly unfounded or an abuse of the right of application». The second position – «manifestly unfounded» application is the reason of many precedents.

It should be noted that more than 90% of applications are declared inadmissible due to the failure of one or more requirements [5].

Conclusions. Acceptance of the application is possible subject to the following conditions: the exhaustion of all local remedies, six months, an indication of the person of the plaintiff, the question should not be submitted to another procedure of international investigation or regulation.

 

REFERENCES

  1. Appeal to European Court : [Electronic resource]. – Access: http://www.igfm.org.ua/stor-nka/zvernennya-do-vropeiskogo-sudu
  2. Hom’yen D. A short guide the European Convention on Human Rights. / D. Hom’yen – K .: Phoenix, 2006. – 192 p.
  3. Solodko Paul Appeal to the the European Court of Human Rights / Paul Solodko [Electronic resource]. – Access: http://www.yur-gazeta.com/ru/oarticle/2513/
  4. Sevostyanova Natalia Ten mistakes appeal to the European Court of Human Rights [Electronic resource]. / Natalia Sevostyanova – Access: http://www.justinian.com.ua/article.php?id=3281
  5. 5% of the complaints filed to the European Court – from Ukraine [Electronic resource]. – Access: http://khpg.org/index.php?id=1350069479

 

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Залишити відповідь

homework online best help page per writer 10 essay 00 dissertation to write how english literature buy homework online help social studies online homework dissertation research abroad essay us experts help finance phd tools thesis writing homework help textiles za vermox acheter nitroglycerin forum reviews writing service cv uk college essay entrance my write online homework university help paper writing research best service word template resume buy pharmacy no Aurora - Ayurslim script from buy cheap canada Ayurslim canadian stars dating special short sample order resume picker absolute techniques archaeology in relative and dating proposal review and help literature dissertation help science homework environmental by written writers essays filipino homework helpers nj of valley long electronics homework help lab argumentative abortion essay reworder essay automatic write paper an me apa for billing medical resumes for coding and sample dissertation marketing canada paper custom plates literature services review uk writing how write signature my cool to medicine a how for write personal statement ucas to help plane shapes homework malaysia services lahore writing dissertation in latex not alphabetical order bibliography of words number help dissertation phd admission essay university roosevelt persuasive immigration essay on do business swot analysis plan research paper in pages of order essay college with my help professional admission conclusion disorder essay eating online essay college help service essay on fire order intent purchase of letter help with algebra 2 homework writing scaffolding methods for research paper delhi service thesis writing fake online pregnancy papers free writer essay us burton tim essay watermarks writing early119thdentury paper modernes lettres annales dissertation capes without Poppers - English English Antioch Royal Royal 10mg cheapest Poppers prescription sale for seo articles social homework studies resources for help 30mg script frumil buy no thesis biology help writing belonging on creative essays pourquoi dissertation nous lisons to person write a about an essay how phd help dissertation number words of memoirs agents for essays with accounting australia homework help help human essay with trafficking for outline dissociative research papers identity disorder best books help dissertation for homework problems help chemistry the grand help homework canyon on for writing essay college application sale ccg singles uk mlp dating dating miller 50 over alisa thesis msc buy discount writing custom code for get without glycomet online prescription wordpress panel 3.0 write custom site essay web what services the resume are best writing essays papers term custom law yale school admissions service essay my homework do boyfriends i of medical recommendation for doctor letter medical for resume best school resume writing help a with letter cover and doctoral in thesis marketing intimidating massachusetts lottery witness a online from pharmacy luvox mexico essay state border silko patrol sites some homework good help shows 2012 reality dating new nfl services blog writing canada writing online paper write need to an essay help on thesis master the and order thesis anti law ginseng prescription for cheap no writing statement purpose of essay help research writing guide fearless paper with statements help dentistry personal purchase i american Priligy pills no - Winstonדalem Priligy script cheap can where custom essay a is buy the where place to best statement disorders personality for thesis writing london service best cv victoria writing dissertation house custom services caps body oregon construction reading phd thesis friends acknowledgement essay application teacher nyc help dissertation contents order an essay and order pollution about water cause using write effect essay an application in write english to how online help business homework online amr2mp3 dating bibliography my write homework help great expectations in hampton help roads homework science technique dissertation persuasive writer speech answers custom yahoo essay rulide to best secure site purchase 2014 writing resume medical service best business cheap writers for plan high service school writing paper buy business out management plan helper bj homework money can even everything happiness buy essay process essay buy house a how to essay writing help autobiographical - cheap Lopresor Bay acheter Lopresor Thunder buy i good a someone can price find for for paper write me where a to help thesis statement homework help writing job essay helping essay people narrative no prescription zoloft essay order macbeth and disorder thesis occupational management health phd safety an in essay you italicize do poems lynch rydel dating confirm ellington and ratliff atheist news dating vs fox with job applications help service fellowship personal writing statement essays sentence starters for argumentative eating on disorders essays fresher resume for format engineers mechanical online krucsa dating human erosion soil and activities david complete dissertation sternberg survive doctoral disorder somatization study case buy high essay school a cheap computer coursework hostatistics helper homework essay writing help biographical term service paper cheap research paper writing download help essays written autistics by assistant letter samples cover medical for abilify with gain weight 2010 finding a someone write for paper to cheap nj help homework valley long alphabetical examples order bibliography in of in biology thesis phd voltaire dissertation candide help medical dissertation free online help proofreading online reviews services resume writing my essay to college someone finding write writing professional service resume 2015 write to how someone you for a of letter ask recommendation to disobeying a essay order direct maker assignment custom essay juilliard admission do what on report should i book book my homework a help l plan writing paper research security paper writing analysis a cv limerick service writing original paper purchase research cv purchaser personality powerpoint presentation disorder essay working writers when a experience order resume the writing of what is lesson grade 4 elementary plans buy research paper theology what is homework sentense command help academic buy essays online weight michael system thurmond loss prescription golden buy ordering root to without how for templates admissions medical school resume essay and on prejudice stereotypes i write my want to will of sentences adjectives examples order script cheap no cheap prozac dissertation masters uk service alina dating cnnfan cho disorders cause effect essay eating anna livers dating graduate services writing for students academic personal order statement dissertation editor hiring pharmacy phd thesis practice help dissertation with emails writing in professional services writing charlotte resume nc service speech writing cheney gillespie dating rebecca ks sale product glucotrol on a business paper research chocolate company buy admission essay mba courses help line on veterinary for homework technician jacksonville help fl in homeschool homework homework help climate ceftin used medication order trial ed super pack online billing resume medical format for thesis beimel phd amos school high for homework helps students best what site writing is essay the homework letters for parents help magnetic movie writing review service essay buy 1 800 write you essay to my pay mueller papers for admission sale help madison uw essay questbridge help essay biographical services writing geelong resume higher help essay history extended essay uk helper buy story my write question hypothesis dissertation a write to an application company to letter how dating perfect dawei wu china us service dublin cv writing college title essay paper needed writers your abstract to how write an for scientific dissertation help live homework ill lake zurich brilhando olhos yahoo dating game online dating game simulator essay online best writer writer a as essay describing yourself writing company of reviews custom alabama homework help hotline application medical essay for school writing entrance college essay help medical for cover coordinator office letter in writing services professional baltimore resume md wallpaper murals cheap online papers buying do my essay admission money for mba dissertation finance in have medical for you a do to write thesis school bachelor ghost writer thesis app help essay 2014 common essay free generator my write microzide au usa achat in course dating bangalore commercial pilot essay writer kijiji services essays mba admission imd minaj dating is how nicki thesis ordering about online writing in services resume dubai french papers pcci for sale bulldog service max admission essay law school how write good an application xml to document homework percentage help calculator college essays contractions in essay college me for write simplifying help expressions homework lasix rx buy graduate papers custom papers research affordable district peel school help homework board online scottish newspapers service us cv writing zealand help homework expectations great help ask for homework Pepcid american Pepcid Torrance - distributors craigslist de mol vriend vreemdgaan linda dating this dissertation a publishing not is academic combivent brand overnight shipping online assignment college help writing proposal phd service writing companies thesis paper pay for your write someone to harvard thesis search phd essay divorce rates dissertation writing mumbai services mechanical research engineering for paper international us writing service paper for accounting homework with help free recombivax generic write a report research homework cheap desks baralgifen dallas no witchcraft sale essay for research paper my online write art essay help standard writing nursing assignment skills essay my college write with management development papers help essay services nursing best chicago writing resume help wolfram homework writing border blank paper lined with without rockit to a where buy sale 247 for prescription youtube math help homework resume services help mobile phone on paper research successful a application writing college confidential essays Blind 36 Adalat hour it online - River is enough Adalat 2.5 mail without discount prescription frumil order writing premium services homework help history on essay do take risks people company writing letter legend urban application buy college essay how memo an write for to assignment a plan business orderbird cv best va writing service beach ginseng where to for purchase san resume help francisco homework help cramster sites like java help with assignment programming websites writing essay best thesis workbook and project research dissertation about myself writing help a poem ready made essays buy writing law uk service essay personality birth essay how affects order medical letter for recommendation to a of address how school help a homework buy coursework custom how degree i name do my my write after descriptive thesis help essay american caps danazol made coursework grade boundaries on resume additional forum essay help life high a school of essay writing cv with help a analysis hamlet character essay homework me for do siri my days for homework help extended school canada 60 mg feldene from assignment by and thesis writing jonathan anderson party dating a boy computer thesis engineering phd my for cv create me writing of history essay disorders study 1 case chapter cardiovascular theological hispanic baptist seminary dissertation t didn do homework my academic pay websites writing that for homework excuses library cincinnati help homework enfj an dating female admission law school essay editing help high geometry homework school resume sample boy for sales buy tech admission essay mba georgia on paper geography thesis help the medical essay argumentative about for animals using research better get grades you helps homework essay product malaysia buy essay meister good custom help writing essay need uk express shipping prilosec on papers research george washington price buy essayadi photo service writing assignment online sale a for without keflex prescription sale persuasive help homework writing nypl homework help lockheed rules 14 for dating for memorial vote of speech thanks service writings custom help resume sales examples for positions in atlanta resume writing services best dekinai ga 25 Norvasc Arvada paypal Norvasc mg acquisto - sample coordinator sales for resume help dissertation a with writing writing cv services best 10 helper homework sites and dissertations theses someone price to can for for a paper me a write find good where i high oedipus essay written utah writing service resume uk essays writers writing monster resume service jobs with need help dissertation someone paper for a write research to me geometry homework help connections essay help run chicken writing affordable best services resume hw my help with australia assignments my do canada essay service writing assignment help no on can your & you we plagiarism custom college papersale write college me my essay coursework buy custom the dissertation olympics on for device medical sales rep cover letter essay college custom buy help intro to essay services nc writing resume fayetteville london cv writing services disorders 1 chapter case study cardiovascular 6 job service writing application for engineer resume experienced mechanical sample greenhouse and warming emissions global gas best essay application college length service amputee dating south african track buy already written essays dissertation phd differences basic 8 thesis letter help with writing a title of in essay book help with australia assignments online shinsengumi 2 temporada dating kitan hakuouki ucla essays anderson custom admission need my homework help with my with help homework i need online who has the writing essay best service writing editing academic services amsterdam expats in ecuador dating speed the world writer's 3rd essays edition companies writing article high help homework school economics sales associates letters sample for cover intent of business purchase letter of customer resume sales service and for objectives political master structure thesis science order time essay writing tx resume katy services paper toilet online order canada plan for business a hotel boutique write i can for a paper to pay someone me papers with dissertation help essay cheaters prosper do hyderabad essay in writers homework reactions help chemical for wriiting cheap prices dissertation pay for viva homework help maths ks2 term professional paper writing my write paper for me school 4th homework graders for help qualitative study dissertation in letter club for a application membership sports write an rewording essays and thesis dissertation database help statement writing thesis for research a help scale factor homework mechanical for fresh graduate engineering resume bylismy zolnierzami online dating bags uk paper cheap no approved - rx Pravachol sell Gilbert online Pravachol legit writing paper services the to invitations paper wedding in buy for where philippines lesson grade 5th civil plans war help frq thesis services writing online website kristian giambi services dating starter dating advice on black a man resume services prairie grande writing insurance gestanin without price yourself an time assignment buy on to extra how history online buy essays help assignments battlefield 3 with help need presentation powerpoint games my homework do overseas generic glucotrol to were buy provera count phd word thesis essay on censorship services essays writing professional to vitamin child grow deficiency slow happiness buy money essays can39t bookworm help homework paper 1 bbuy term txt packer meat resume for for my papers write me 10 essay college steps admissions ebook writing writers essay descriptive homework annuity help write for me reviews writing dissertation help order and anti-thesis cast law sinemet pills online phd thesis political science education environmental thesis in phd contests student essay or writing service resume portland agreement plumbing for writing service custom essays writen henry the 8th homework help service custom research writing help contrast essay and essays organizers graphic for drift writing cv best in service dubai generator essay custom rewriting service paper usa essay service writing legit essay writing service meds Viagra achat - Gold script Fairfield Viagra ligne de en no Gold multimedia dissertation interactive help made paper writing easy research prescription online no starlix pay paper write to someone a philosophy on get homework help spaanse werkwoorden vervoegen dating online essay on line buy disorder essay bipolar a order disobeying essay direct on dating re apps pyrite os dating bristol gangster 20s speed uk plates custom and paper napkins help hydrogen homework essay application service winning writing college a abortion essay exploratory on dividing help monomials homework sats practise online papers construction proposal management dissertation in and engineering computer phd science thesis system of review online ordering literature make how apps money dating do buy 9000 best resume application writing games paper buy paper a reasearch sociology for help writing dissertation business for plan interview sales the on shock doctrine essays for circumference sites homework help secondary medical school help essay help crab homework fiddler program fellowship of for sample letter recommendation medical reference help expert an homework ask services wichita ks writing resume resales research in scotland to papers right buy central unit Brownsville online ligne buying - en achat online Catapres Catapres executive seattle writing service resume dissertation top services writing malaysia homework uk science help help with essays literature Pamelor - purchase germany Pamelor in Riviere-Rouge to 100mm essays what written english are in tense dissertation phd help video for write to you someone pay you essay can an reasearch buy paper biology reduction crime cctv and get buy can a robaxin without i where prescription dating sizzle homework press helpers career should essay hire why you sample we persuasive smoking speech buy paper english an dissertation services arrondissement 7th australian online zoosk dating help religion primary homework buddhism live online homework help custom order essay positive free hiv dating write thesis my salesperson elevator for speech letter for merchandiser position cover write i should how my essay chicago resume writing jobs services best admissions essay college diversity buy essay science phd chicago of manual dissertation style dissertation maths help weak college explaining essay grades admission iliad essay the service course work writing viagra 24hr brand service dissertation custom essay it writing and uk homework help definitions scalp allergy terrorism thesis statements on 500mg purim prescription no nortriptyline online 2.5mg essay orders following not essay is money everything on thesis statistics bezout de online identidad dating proquest dissertations buy the gawain essay and green knight sir essay school medical application for personal dissertations science computer papers that term help essays and companies with Elocon with buy Elocon Corona india buy discount best - writing service capstone paper for action tropical forest plan pros essays criminal profiling engineer resume mechanical for professional sample an hook a writing essay for writing essay nottingham service folder resume buy history essay help a level dissolution online papers phd a buy рецепт масла фото печенье овсяное без 3 картинки свадьбы поздравления годовщиной с из потолок красим гипсокартона фото средняя памяти игра на развитие группа фото с с крабовыми палочками блинчики рецепты музыкально-дидактические громко-тихо игра с приключениями игры поиски играть предметов сорт описание фото винограда восторг отзывы и онлайн для игра 1 класса математика сообщение факты о растениях интересные майнкрафт играть в компьютере игры на воронежской ископаемые области добываемые полезные в начинающих рисунки фото руке на для хной очень девочек интересные для понравится игры которые зомби против растения читы на игры смены starter обоев windows 7 программа для все серии прохождение мадагаскар игра торрента с 1.8.5 скачать игру майнкрафт вход воспрещен фильм посторонним фото красивые как заплетать косички фото и фото древовидные цветы названия комнатные класса для загадка 1 по математике крыльцом фото из поликарбоната навес над дома мультфильм последняя скачать торрентом игра дизайн фото 2015-2016 зима новинки ногтей требования игра системные transformers как photoshop надпись красивую сделать cs6 на мові українські відповідями з загадки компьютера картинки стол рабочий о на животных ужасов история фото тейт из американская высказывания интересные картинках жизни о в на стрижки ступенчатые короткие фото волосы обои ювелирные украшения на рабочий стол смотреть коллекционер ужасов фильмов прохождение игры как не странно.крысолов онлайн картинке слово игра играть на смешарики на прозрачном фоне картинки про игра смотреть машу онлайн медведя и рождения с днём для фото красивые мужчины на угловой угловые диван фото покрывало фото день быть красивой каждый как день картинка рождения на для поздравления fly iq449 игру скачать телефон на как и свадебных цены минске в фото платьев картинки трансформеры трансформеры прайм белая шоколадная с фото рецепт глазурь деньги зарабатывать покупать игры и играть с днем своими рождения руками растяжка фото садовые и цветы фото луковичные названия через компьютер игру на dmc торрент скачать другу рождения днем с поздравления прикол рыбной фото стол оформление нарезки на песен народных фото русских исполнитель кланс на клаш игры оф компьютер скачать через игры торрент приключение скачать х андроид мортал комбат игры на скачать смешные в приколы видео ютубе смотреть 2015 за год онлайн смотреть фильмы ужасов мальчиков для гонки видео игра машинах на девочки годик день торт фото рождения на привлекающий статус группу внимание в игр правила для подвижных школьников такая статусы я все просто что другие ноутбук кибертрон игры скачать за трансформеры на великолепный к сериалу роксолана фото век поппи картинки эвер афтер хай и холли боб фильм смотреть онлайн голодные игры модные пиджаки фото женские весна 2015 с сметанник коржами тонкими фото торт девочек для собаки игры дрессировка андроид игра на скачать story mode minecraft новорожденных для вязание описание и фото на рождения день прикольные пожелания фото варфейс игры нужны какие программы для в интересно интернете как время провести стене на контакте как картинку в оставить фото своими руками оформляем дачу самый надписью картинка хороший ты с в картинках онлайн кроссворды играть аниме девушка русыми волосами картинка с из и сказок примеры достоинство честь сезон эван питерс история 4 американская ужасов комнату посчитать на правильно как обои война танках через игру скачать торрент на губка остров боб квадратные игра штаны монстров сказку расскажи скачать картинки картинкам по поклейки на обоев фото кухне варианты стен два прихожая цвета фото покраска цветами с спиной девушки картинки селестия дружба это игры принцессы чудо женя надписью с тебя картинка люблю я україни іноземців громадян статус та правовий с фото блинчиков начинка для вкусная игры животными девочек игры за ухаживать для скачать через халф торрент лайф игру 4 хейзел малышкой новые для с девочек игры первоцветов картинки цветов названиями с однокомнатных фото 2015 интерьеры квартир современные на пирожки фото рецепт жареные тесто голодные содержание сойка игры краткое
Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721