Problems of Implementation of the Constitutional and Legal Status of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine in Relations with the Constitutional Court of Ukraine

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

     The article analyzes the current problems of implementation of the constitutional and legal status of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, which occur while performing the parliament’s functions in the relations with the Constitutional Court of Ukraine.

     Key words: parliament, constitutional jurisdiction body, system of checks and balances.

     Problem statement. Establishing the legal statehood, strengthening the principles of rule of law (Constitution) and the need to ensure a real separation of powers and, eventually, constitutional rights and freedoms of an individual in the modern Ukraine actualizes the necessity to study the problem of ensuring apolitical status of the constitutional jurisdiction body in the system of checks and balances [ 3; 124].

     Analysis of the latest studies. Scope of the study is reflected in the works of such native scientists as V. Shapoval, A. Sovhyri, V. Telipka, H. Fedorenko, R. Martynyuk, V. Kovalchuk, Yu. Barabash, and others.

Objective of the study is to analyze the current problems of implementation of the constitutional and legal status of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine in relations with the Constitutional Court of Ukraine and the search for ways and means to overcome these problems.

     Presentation of the main material of the study. First of all, we consider it appropriate to draw attention to the issue of normative regulation of the Court’s formation agenda. Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, as well as President of Ukraine and the Congress of Judges of Ukraine elect a third of the members. However, situation when some of the authorized bodies fail to appoint judges timely remains unregulated. Definitely, it jeopardizes the exercise of their constitutional powers. The history if Ukraine already knows such case, when in October 2005, in connection with the expiration of the nine-year term of office of sixteen judges, the President of Ukraine and the Congress of Judges of Ukraine appointed its quota of judges (in sixes). However, the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, which was to appoint four judges, was unable to make these appointments, because most of the people’s deputies avoided voting procedure for political reasons. In such a way, the parliamentary faction, opposing the President of Ukraine, sought to prevent the possibility of viewing amendments as of December 8, 2004 introduced to the Main Law of Ukraine by the newly formed Constitutional Court of Ukraine by request of the President of Ukraine [4; 19]. The activity of the Constitutional Court during 2005 and early 2006 was actually locked and such a precedent is absolutely unacceptable, because the lack of control power may lead to a situation, in which legislative and executive powers would become immune to any control. Therefore, to ensure the real independence of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine in the system of checks and balances, we consider it appropriate to draw attention to a proposal of R. Martyniuk who offers to secure regulations (preferably at the level of the Main Law of Ukraine and in the Law of Ukraine «On the Constitutional Court of Ukraine») concerning the fact that «the judges of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine shall continue to perform their duties until the inauguration of newly elected judges» [3; 124].
Judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine assumes the office on the day of taking the oath of a judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine during the meeting of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. This procedural point is important, because in 2006 there was a situation, when the people’s deputies blocked taking the oath by newly appointed judges of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. Scientists propose to resolve this issue by deleting the rule of necessity to take oath when assuming a position from the Law of Ukraine «On the Constitutional Court» or provide the procedure of taking office, when it is impossible to take the oath in the meeting of the Verkhovna Rada by taking the oath in some other place or without taking it [6; 421]. Such reasoning is not entirely justified, because, firstly, the fact of taking the oath by a newly appointed judge allows to bring him or her to responsibility for its violation, and secondly – logically, if the oath is taken exactly in the meeting of the legislative authority, which, according to John Stuart Mill, functions as eyes, ears and voice of the people in a representative democracy. If some contradictions arise concerning individual candidates, then it is necessary to provide mechanism of coordination of contradictions.
It is also important to pay attention to the possibility of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine and the President of Ukraine not only to elect but to dismiss judges. If to consider it possible that the dismissal of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine is not carried out on the grounds under Art. 126 of the Constitution of Ukraine, then it clearly denies equal status, independence and balance of all branches of government, violates the system of checks and balances and unduly expands the prerogatives of the Parliament and the President of Ukraine in the sphere of constitutional justice. In fact, it denies the principle of the independence of justice, because the possibility of removing judges can be applied in the event of dissatisfaction with the decision for political reasons. To avoid this situation, we consider it appropriate to provide a clear list of reasons for early termination of a judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine or transfer powers to the early termination of office of judges to the competence of the court.
It is also important to note that the possibility of objective attitude to the President of Ukraine not only on the part of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, but on the part of the Supreme Court of Ukraine in the process of impeachment is increasingly questioned. This is primarily due to the influence of the President of Ukraine on the formation of state bodies. As mentioned, the President of Ukraine appoints 6 judges of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine and also has the ability to dismiss them. Thus, in accordance with the Law of Ukraine «On the Constitutional Court», to decide in a proceeding of a respective constitutional petition of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine and provide the necessary conclusions, it is necessary to present votes of not less than 10 judges of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. As for the Supreme Court of Ukraine, the situation seems simpler, because usually the judges of the Supreme Court of Ukraine are those who have 15 years of experience and have already been elected by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine in perpetuity. However, such a position may be assumed by the judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, and this also allows for the President to form the needed team of committed people who will take the decision in favor of the Head of the state for the time necessary. In this case, it is unwise to rely on the impartiality of judges. Indeed, in such circumstances, they cannot carry out their activities independently, and it certainly does not help Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine resolve political crisis that may arise in the state under certain conditions.
It is necessary to pay special attention to question the quality of draft laws adopted recently. The people’s deputies have repeatedly had the opportunity to appeal to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on the recognition of the unconstitutionality of legal acts of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. In particular, the constitutional ruling on termination of proceedings concerning the unconstitutionality of Acts of Parliament adopted in the premises of the «Ukrainian House» on January 21 and February 1, 2000 (resolution No.2-уп as of June 27, 2000), the court found these acts being beyond consideration, as this question «has a regulational, procedural, political and moral meaning, and decisions made in the «Ukrainian House» are, in fact, a part of the political process» [7]. Some researchers in the field of constitutional law believe that this statement of the Court is at least controversial, and for good reason. They point out that the Constitutional Court of Ukraine as the sole body of constitutional jurisdiction, which provides protection of the Constitution of Ukraine and provides an interpretation of its rules, has exclusive competence to determine the legitimacy (origin and activity) of any constitutionally established authority. And the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine is entitled by delegated legitimacy based on the fundamental act of the people – the Constitution, so that in certain circumstances it is able to lose it. And just when it acts completely unconstitutional, violating p. 5, Art. 83 of the Constitution of Ukraine, which provides that the procedure of work of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine is established by the Constitution and Regulations of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. Therefore, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, considering its vocation, is entitled with the power not only to establish the legitimacy of the acts of the highest authority in the state, but also its activity [2]. On the decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine in case of the procedure of voting and reconsideration of laws by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine as of July 7, 1998 No. 11-рп/98, the Court determines that «a people’s deputy of Ukraine has no right to vote for other people’s deputies of Ukraine during the meeting of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine» [5; 257-263]. However, this conclusion is no longer applied when considering the submissions of the unconstitutionality of acts of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine for this reason. The main reason for rejection of the Constitutional Court to institute proceedings in such cases is the lack of evidence of the presence of the people’s deputies in the courtroom during voting


LITERATURE:

1. Barabash Yu. H. Democracy in System of Values of the Constitutional Order (based on Practice of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine) / Yu. H. Barabash // Bulletin of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. – 2009. – No.5. – P. 91-92.
2. Kovalchuk V. B. The Role and Place of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine in the System of Government of Ukraine: [Digital resource]. / V. B. Kovalchuk. – Retrieved from : http://naub.org.ua/?p=740
3. Martyniuk R. S. Constitutional Jurisdiction. Problems of the Constitutional Court in Ukraine / R. S. Martyniuk // Political Reform as Viewed by Experts: meaning of Public Consultations. – Kyiv, 2007. – 180 p.
4. Rudyk P. A. Constitutional Reform in Ukraine: Problems and Perspectives / P. A. Rudyk. – Kyiv: Atika, 2006. – 256 p.
5. Ruling of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine as of 27.06.2000 No. 2-уп/2000 : [Digital resource]. – Retrieved from: http://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v002u710-00.
6. Sovgyria O. V. Constitutional Law of Ukraine. Complete course: textbook/ O. V. Sovgyria, N. H. Shuklina. – 2nd ed., revised and added. – К. : Yurinkom Inter, 2012. – 544 p.
7. The Constitutional Court of Ukraine: Ruling. Conclusions. 1997-2001 / Execut. edit. Cand. Sc. (Law) P. B. Yevgrafov. – К. : Yurinkom Inter, 2001. – P. 257-263.

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Залишити відповідь

frq essay help in thesis master science proposal computer my name style calligraphy write paypal service writing cv us defense psychology dissertation essay i cant help my do college speeches buy step with help and decimals homework fractions multi equations help homework college physics phd thesis mechanical writers anti federalist papers letter write own my recommendation a caryl new essay world order phillips history my write me help paper dating tilburg online tatio anxiety dating someone sayings with funny writing academic phd bachelor essay disorders eating research where to prescription without capoten get order websites ukala dating reviews conclusion dissertation a purchase thesis statement my do sale cheap paper term generous essay friend writing paper blank online qartulad dating online nakiami weliwadi clarinex manufacturer of who is the essays 0com buy essay community on help how your to papers research technology on quote the crashers wedding dating master essay admission speech hire writer wedding dissertation editing cheap quick homework help shelbyville illinois library public makes for personal school medical what good statement a disorder personality studies antisocial case hiring letter for job application online for dating yahoo free dating business a phd student fellow for assignment college my me do computer programming assignment help outlд±ne military expenditures essay somebody pay my to essay make capital thesis working on management master huntington help ca homework beach coursework service cheap writing papers to research buy gold svizzera viagra acquista my business should plan write who harvard business plan universit y write gcse drama essays software paper mac writing research online helper essay francais my homework do en a homework website for help homework trigonometry helper money for write articles studies personality disorder multiple case disorders essays on anxiety pay in hours essay to write 8 essay disorder traumatic paper stress post professional cheap order online viagra bitesize bbc help homework ks3 homework helper uk dating belgium women drugs zithromax canada homework differential help resume in workplace the office samples paper management front term conflict homework forgot to my do writer code essay discount resume technical skills for engineer mechanical buying group business plan sociology dissertation improvement grant nsf katy services resume writing tx bergeron citation for mla harrison a is long thesis phd biology how for coreg anxiety online college sell papers funding dissertation sources and vartan michael dating jennifer garner alias illegal is paper buying a online intercourse prostate cancer online canada sites dating postage best 2012 homework alabama library help public live experience application without letter lady sales for help homework ict test online papers littell homework help algebra mcdougal 1 pfalzwerke dating online ludwigshafen intimidating most voice order space essay speech adults for help therapy with essays paper writing reflection halle online dissertation mlu on web help homework the synthesis ap lang essay help you my math can do homework thesis writing jonathan and assignment by anderson pdf advice tin saloon lizzie dating contest dissertation medication urispas your master thesis to publish how it essay dissertation writing and custom service school writing application for medical essays secondary help essay prompt uc 1 writing essay service urgent essay will write who my rationale phd thesis essay questions for medea bhu in swamy dating temple varaha bangalore a how essay to write company london writing cv trends research forces buy best and co inc and dating sulli services choiza confirmed white hire paper copywriters writing malaysia dissertation ottawa service essay house renting an a buying apartment vs barker pat border crossing essay order alphabetical are in bibliographies tablets buy claritin safe overnight 1767 buy minipress the the essays of on why essay started power war cold art help uk online dissertation letter a recommendation to of someone ask write how do you dating online dzordzijas likums are essay writing how services reliable estate template real proposal purchase writing uk online assignment term paper online buy scams paper writing services thesis saipan filipina masters service dating funbook where my i write paper college can to someone find letter cover salary do expectations be marijuana essay medical should legalized for purposes dissertation with help writing resume by written essay high student writing resume best professional services adelaide christianity aged dating middle relationships compulsive thesis obsessive disorder writing essay done nursing paper service writing disorder compulsive literature review obsessive resume rated top services writing professional essay writing help dvd application college an membership sports letter for application club a write in plan of india 11th fiveyear my buy homework for essay ged help online quick claritin value essays about essay philosophy of volunteering services.co.uk essay a with writing help thesis anniversary application college online edition 25th help essay best writer company essay on thesis phd energy solar prefieren hermano dating a yahoo mi papers free legal online cheap buy online uk essays reviews writing help managerial homework help economics thesis system ordering conclusion for dosage abilify depression reviews help writing best binding thesis cheap oxford papers police argumentative brutality websites essays urdu freshers mechanical samples resume engineers for writing vows my i need help essays by addison written joseph vampires les sur calmet dissertation de dissertation mort peine pharmacy fosamax mexico online from to english papers do online make custom paper writing resume executive dc services on mathematics papers mifflin houghton help message ancient with of online homework letter cover service representative customer resume disorder anxiety social research paper dissertation london services help proposal kenya writing in companies wedding help my speech writing an autobiography help writing cialis cialis pharmacy forum analysis help financial homework papers online otago exam finance studies solutions online free harvard grant writing with case course do my i homework cant why topics paper for medea dating mile filme dublado 8 online completo homework sites done have my which to i can pay essay on holocaust the reflective singapore essay writer application proposal phd research preface acknowledgements dissertation test papers eamcet for online mock engineering assignment help quality management in tourism dissertation
Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721