MEASURES OF THE CRIMINAL LAW AIMED AT LEGAL PERSONS FOR COMMISSION OF TERRORIST CRIMES: INNOVATIONS ANALYSIS

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Problem setting. On May 23rd, 2013, the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine passed the Law of Ukraine “On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine to Implement the Action Plan for the European Union Liberalization of the Visa Regime for Ukraine, Regarding Liability of Legal Entities” (hereinafter called the Law on Liability of Legal Entities). This Law was adopted pursuant to the European Union – Ukraine Visa Dialogue, which required the reform of Ukrainian anticorruption legislation as a part of the action plan on liberalization of the EU visa regime for Ukraine [5]. Moreover, it was caused by commitment of Ukraine to a number of international acts, including the UN Convention against Transnational Organized Crime and Corruption, Criminal Law Convention on Corruption of the Council of Europe, Convention on Combating Terrorism of the Council of Europe and others [7].

This law was the third and finally successful attempt to establish criminal liability for legal persons: the first was a suggestion made back in 1993 – 1997 in one of two projects of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (hereinafter called the CCU), and the second was supposed to be implemented in 2010 – 2011 along with a package of new anti-corruption laws. In early 2013, the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine was filed by a similar bill, which was rejected in April, and then on May 14th, 2013, deputies of different parliamentary factions introduced compromissory bill that was consequently adopted by the parliament.

Law on Liability of Legal Entities will come in force on September 1st, 2014, and therefore the problem of criminal liability of legal persons in general is particularly topical. Furthermore, of a special interest is the application of measures of criminal law for committing of crimes, stipulated in Art. 258 – 258-5 of the CCU (hereinafter called the terrorist crimes).

Last scientific researches and publications analysis. Such prominent Ukrainian and Russian scientists researched the issue of bringing legal person to criminal liability: Tagantsev N., Emelyanov V., Kraynyk G., Poznyshev S. and others. However, has not been done comprehensive research of measures of criminal law aimed at legal entities for commission of terrorism offences in the context of changes in the Ukrainian criminal law.

Formulation of the article’s purpose. The task of this research is to provide a detailed analysis of the appropriateness of criminal liability of legal entities in general and evaluation of innovations in Ukrainian criminal law concerning the liability of legal entities particularly.

The statement of basic material of investigation. As it is known, according to the current CCU, criminal, notably of the terrorist crimes, can only be a sane person who committed the crime at the age when he can face criminal responsibility due to the law (Art. 18 of the CCU). For a long period of time Ukrainian legal paradigm of understanding of criminal liability did not recognize legal entities as criminals, since this would be a contradiction to the principle of personal responsibility [6, P. 212]. On the contrary, the vast majority of states have long been successfully applying institution of criminal liability of legal entities for committing different crimes. Moreover, these states belong both to the Anglo-Saxon system of law
(the USA, Canada, the UK) [7], and to the Romance-Germanic (Denmark, Lithuania, France, the Netherlands etc.) [8].

Among European countries only Bulgaria, Italy, Germany, Ukraine and Russia are using administrative sanctions against legal entities. However, Bulgaria is currently in the process of drafting new legislation that will provide the criminal liability of corporations [8]. Significant changes, the contents of which are discussed below, are also expected in Ukrainian criminal legislature.

Russian scientists in the field of criminal law characterize legal persons as impossible to apply the appropriate criminal penalties to. They reckon that the reason for that is the legal nature of legal entities: they are intrinsically fictitious, and thus they lack the will, an integral part of the guilt – to commit an action in general, and socially dangerous one in particular. Considering this, it is impossible to prove the guilt – a mandatory feature of the subjective side of the each crime – of the legal entity. They also states that such measures of criminal coercion can hide the real criminals who are guilty of committing crimes that the legal entity will face criminal liability for [6, P. 213 – 215].

However, such statements seem to be doubtful and hopelessly outdated. Solution for these problems has been found long ago: supporters of the criminal liability of legal entities indicate that the objectification of the will can only be found in purposeful action (inaction), the act of both physical and legal person, and that is the only form in which will can be expressed. In addition, it is claimed that the principle of individualization of punishment creates the problem of a technical nature only, namely the problem of burden-sharing of criminal responsibility, since the liability of legal persons does not exclude the criminal liability of individuals [8]. All represented above has influenced principles of the Law on the Liability of Legal Entities, which this article is devoted to.

Mentioned law amends the General Part of the CCU, which is supplemented by Section XIV-1 Measures of criminal law aimed at legal entities. Thus, according to p. 1 of the Art. 96-3 of this Section, the grounds for the application of measures of criminal law to legal entities are:

  • commission of any of the crimes specified in Art. 209, 306, first and second parts of Art. 368-3, first and second parts of Art. 368-4, Art. 369, 369-2 of the CCU on behalf of and in interest of the legal entity;
  • commission of any of the crimes specified in Art. 258 – 258-5 of the CCU by an authorized person on behalf of the legal entity [6].

The object of research of this paper is analysis of the last point, namely grounds of liability of legal persons on whose behalf terrorist crimes are committed. Furthermore, the p. 1 of the Art. 96-9 of this Law envisages the types of measures of criminal law for committing terrorist crimes: the basic one is elimination and additional is confiscation of property.

Thus, it is believed that the adoption of the discussed law is ​​a significant step forward in the process of fighting against crimes in general and terrorist crimes in particular. Moreover, these innovations cannot be regarded as groundless since international treaties, ratified by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, and national legislation, determined its foundation.

Proof of this is that pursuant to Art. 10 of the Council of Europe Convention on the Prevention of Terrorism, each Party shall adopt such measures as may be necessary, in accordance with its legal principles, to establish the liability of legal entities for participation in the offences set forth in Articles 5 to 7 and 9 of this Convention. Additionally, it is noted that such liability shall be without prejudice to the criminal liability of the natural persons who have committed the offences [1]. The latter statement is reflected in amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, caused by adoption of the Law on Liability of Legal Entities. These changes, complemented by the p. 8 of the Art. 214 imply that information about the legal entity, whom the measures of criminal law can be applied against, is registered in the Unified register of pre-trial investigation by the investigator or prosecutor immediately after person has received notice of being suspected for commission of any of the crimes above on behalf or in interest of the legal person. A legal proceeding against the person is done simultaneously with the criminal proceedings in which the person is informed about suspicion [6].

Furthermore, according to Art. 24 of the Law of Ukraine “On Combating Terrorism”, the organization, that is responsible for the commission of the terrorist act and declared a terrorist by the court, must be eliminated and its property be confiscated [3]. Currently, there is no legislation that explains, how to implement the procedures, described in those legislative provisions. However, it is obvious that the elucidation of the facts and circumstances of the committing of actions, which constitute the objective side of the crime, should occur in criminal proceedings. Ukraine is moving along the path that has already been passed by most of the world by recognizing the possibility of prosecution of legal entities in accordance with the principles of criminal law [8].

It should, however, be taken into consideration, that the Law on Liability of Legal Entities establishes not criminal, but quasi-criminal liability of legal persons, eliminating the necessity to amend the provisions of the CCU on questions of the perpetrator, the grounds of liability and subjective side of the crime. Therefore, under the provisions of the law mentioned above, measures of criminal law, but not a punishment, are applied to legal entities. This approach is not unique Ukrainian experience, since similar solutions of the problem is practiced by Sweden, Poland, Slovakia and Azerbaijan [8].

Conclusion. Innovation in Ukrainian criminal law on the liability of legal persons is a step forward in the theory and practice of combating crimes in general and terrorist crimes in particular.

 

REFERENCES

  1. Конвенція Ради Європи // Офіційний вісник України. – 2007. – № 65. – Ст. 2536.
  2. Кримінальний кодекс України від 5 квітня 2001 р. // Відомості Верховної Ради України. – 2001. – № 25-26. – Ст. 131.
  3. Про боротьбу з тероризмом: Закон України від 20 березня 2003 р. // Відомості Верховної Ради України. – 2003. – № 25. – Ст. 180.
  4. Про внесення змін до деяких законодавчих актів України щодо виконання Плану дій щодо лібералізації Європейським Союзом візового режиму для України стосовно відповідальності юридичних осіб : Закон України від 23 травня 2013 р. // Офіційний вісник України. – 2013. – № 47. – Ст. 1686.
  5. Ukraine: Criminal Responsibility for Legal Entities Introduced : [Електронний ресурс]. – Режим доступу : http://www.loc.gov/lawweb/servlet/lloc_news?disp3_l205403620_text
  6. Емельянов В. П. Терроризм и преступления с признаками терроризирования: уголовно-правовое исследование. – СПб.: Юридический центр Пресс, 2002. – 291 с.
  7. Крайник Г. С. Теоретичний і практичний аспект визнання юридичної особи суб’єктом злочину / Г. С. Крайник / : [Електронний ресурс]. – Режим доступу : http://nauka.jur‑academy.kharkov.ua/download/el_zbirnik/1.2013/Krainik.pdf
  8. Рябошапка Р. Г. Закон про відповідальність юридичних осіб / Р. Г. Рябошапка / Бюлетень Міністерства юстиції України. – 2013. – № 11. : [Електронний ресурс]. Режим доступу : http://tiukraine.org/system/files/docs/news/quo_vadis.pdf

 

У статті розглянуті особливості змін українського кримінального законодавства стосовно відповідальності юридичних осіб. Зокрема, досліджено питання застосування до них заходів кримінально-правового характеру.

Ключові слова: юридична особа, суб’єкт злочину, заходи кримінально-правового характеру.

 

The article describes the features of changes in Ukrainian criminal legislation concerning liability of legal entities. In particular, the questions about application of measures of the criminal law to legal persons were researched.

Key words: legal entity, subject of crime, measures of the criminal law.

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Залишити відповідь

school writing service law paper polygamist dating website writing free help essays dissertation on franchising written essays buy pre buy articles cheap resume admissions graduate college buying uk students essays dyslexia helps paper colored 2 help interprise homework buy in india thesis help and dissertation proposal dissertation effects wellbutrin withdrawal cause does top essay service medical to write statement for for personal what a school distefano homework biology matthew by helpers homework help geography on homework help report book benadryl patient assistance apotheke Root free shipping Golden - Beach Golden no Long prescription delivery Root schweiz buy motivate what me my to can homework do writing custom sites essay resume healthcare service best dc writing i help autobiography my need writing mg Erythromycin mg 20 - perscription 100 Erythromycin canada Kamloops sale from no writer article professional essay service writing paper jobs intent order watch criminal and law dating guys free black papers birth order research essay proposal project service community library help columbus homework i homework didn't poem do my Gold - Viagra where Viagra to Gold rx Irving no purchase with editing service admissions essay essay graduate studies writers plan buy sell business for and williamsburg services resume writing va Somna-Ritz Sherbrooke - england Somna-Ritz Forte buy for sale canada Forte a research of chronological paper order Lakeland a Benicar natural Benicar - 40 mg essay common app personal custom essays admissions written to lisinopril best generic order place resume writing winnipeg service site best micardis secure purchase to dissertation doctoral help jorge bergoglio helping develop students thesis statements buy resume templates 10 free Cystone Cystone - buy netherlands in Provo 2 tadacip reflective i essay what write on should my for cover application medical letter school homework history texas help research paper outline of disorder bipolar outline for statement school medical personal directory thesis phd olympics dating 2012 holt olivia radio phd cognitive mitola thesis paper my blogspot write phonology a purchase dissertation n natural business medical plan supply for company writing 2014 resume best chicago services help language arts homework how to 3 write college page application essay homework math help grade 5th write a help paper to english homework help grammar customized dissertation us uk cheapest info help essay essay services writing usa pharmacy indian Garland buy pharmacy 40mg - online Valparin Valparin who refused their homework student help disorders eating papers on research 1969 michael networks dating williams assignement my do help dissertation hypothesis a boutique business hotel buy plan for a gladiators homework help ne do homework demek for paper research writing service writer thesis hire costs services writing grant comprar caps cernos electrical sample for mep resume engineer cv editing service essay on plagiarism dating vrouwen service iraanse research custom college written papers fsu help essay phd australian thesis top services for accountants writing resume estate letter purchase to real of intent sample card thesis statement credit shopping and wilson edmund of pros essays essay cons online the online research online a purchasing paper essay save the essay music programs stubborn of recommendation asked me write boss my to own letter steffen dissertation annika proofing dissertation to dissertation write where buy atrophy muscular spinal paper notes of research native a on son essay homework help paid paper pads custom dissertation timetable proposal papers disorder help attention for research deficit essay writing need effects of gm essay with help thesis statements guidelines writing paper term for should own their university pay education students essay my i history on should write what paper services ma writing resume worcester memoriam essays in a.h.h on russia a dissertation on good we for essay an will write you of paper business research to dissertation buy where start thesis s pay essay the forward it about movie speech buy informative keywords mechanical for engineering resume texas help essay am prescription York canadian sell without pharmacy - Lanoxin Lanoxin New from sell essay site bengali deliberer dissertation convaincre persuader bio my homework help with 101 cheap online buy Furacin Richmond rx buying Furacin - without writing help letter homework essay cheap kathy peiss amusements do my dissertation uk dissertation custom writing help essays buy to online stories original studies neurogenic disorders and on communication case short me write my for coursework dissertation acknowledgements in buy essay a perssasive essay do services work really writing services copyediting speech persuasive help writing book dating double pdf your kaufen flagyl generika online Gardens 2.5 enough Fluoxetine is Miami it - Fluoxetine my homework do show math work se ovral loss quick egg diet weight application writing introduction essay editing essay service cheap buy college einstein albert homework help custom essay writing jobs i where written for an get essay me can in write my paper apa format writing academic paper birth about influence personality essay on of order writing minneapolis service resume mn dating evolution and potassium-argon creationism 36 ddavp hr best what services the essay is to online term buying guide papers ladders resume cost writing service the on in essay favourite my newspapers role essay on society hobby medical professionals curriculum for vitae sample with outline paper help research an essay malaysia buy product greece history homework help economics masters thesis for assistant receptionist medical letter cover services writing cheap will homework helper economics writing custom medical dissertation service canada buy paypal abilify online paper writings research homework budget help essays me for results dissertation help assignment help malaysia in essay hire should we you of why sales associate for resume sample science homework helper earth birth regulating after cycle control help to homework do forgot essay expository german town college essay about sample my absolute ppt dating to without prescription where brafix purchase power have you made a point presentation for custom freelance writing websites academic services cambridge essay buy how paper style apa to help essay guide custom essay writing com custom admissions essay coding for resume billing medical sample and essay order hymenoptera on dissertation upenn submission develop how an to essay male reviews mg 20 sexual tonic 10 essays page custom clonidine compare where to dissertations buy breaking essay contest barriers is what custom writing services statement school personal of examples for medical
Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3722

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3722