A BOOK REVIEW ON “THE PRESS AND THE COLD WAR

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

                                   Paul Brodoway ( Alberta, Canada)

The University of Alberta

Секція (Етно-, соціо- та психолінгвістика у навчанні професійної англійської)

A BOOK REVIEW ON “THE PRESS AND THE COLD WAR”

 Статтю присвячено огляду проблеми взаємозв’язку американського уряду та преси, що порушується в книзі «Преса та холодна війна» Джеймса Аронсона

Ключові слова: холодна війна, преса, уряд, політика.

 Статья посвящена  проблеме взаимосвязи американского правительства и прессы, чтоподнимается в книге «Пресса и холодная война» Джеймса Аронсона

Ключевые слова: холодная война, пресса, правительство, политика.

 This article is devotedto the problem of the relationships between the American governmentand the pressraised inthe book “ThePressand the Cold War” by JamesAronson

Keywords: cold war, the press, the government, policy.

James Aronson is one of those rare breed of men who did not allow ambition to get in the way of his principles.  A graduate of Harvard and the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism, he discovered, soon after entering the world of journalism, there existed amongst the major newspapers, “censorship so subtle that it was invisible.”  This led him to quit working for the commercial press and to become involved in the alternative press.

Aronson became a founding member of the National Guardian in 1948, and eventually its editor.  His analysis of Cold War Journalism, in which he focuses on the relationships between the American government, the military and the press, as each struggles to deal with the menace of communism, is insightful, revealing and objective.  As a result of his analysis, Aronson contends that after World War II the press became “to a large degree the voluntary arm of established power.” (24)

After reading The Press and the Cold War, it is difficult to imagine how anyone could finish reading this interesting and provocative work without being influenced towards a reconsideration of the various topics discussed in the book, such as Truman’s victory over Dewey, McCarthyism, the Korean War, the Cuban missile crisis and the Viet Nam War.  Because Aronson relies upon extensive quotations from leading American newspapers to support his thesis that the press is the voluntary arm of established power, he is able to cite specific instances to add further weight to his argument.  He provides a particularly revealing account of the hysteria that the press whipped up against Henry Wallace.

Wallace had been Vice President of the United States when America entered World War II, but Roosevelt found it politically expedient to replace him with Harry Truman in 1944.  In 1948 Wallace decided to run for the Presidency, but refused to follow Truman’s example of taking a tough stand against Communism in order to avoid being labelled as soft on communism.  Largely as a result of his stand, Wallace was derided by the press, and many of his followers were pelted with eggs and tomatoes at the National convention of their party.

Interestingly, the policies proposed by Wallace were warmly received in Moscow, so that United States Ambassador Walter Bedell Smith felt constrained to call on foreign minister Vyacheslav Molotov to emphasize that the policies advocated by Wallace would never be implemented by the United States.  At the end of his bristling statement he offered to leave the way open for further dialogue so as to reduce tensions between Russia and America.  This platitudinous statement was given without the expectation that Molotov would respond favourably to it.  When Molotov offered to talk immediately about settling difficulties between the two countries, Washington was so taken back that the situation became embarrassing because it became obvious that the Americans had no intention of talking things out.  The headline in the Los Angeles Times read “Russian Note Arouses Suspicion of Truman”. (42) This loss of equilibrium by the American press was short lived as the very same evening another Los Angeles paper boldly stated that: “U.S. Won’t Bow to Russ.” (42)

The above account is one of a number of accounts that Aronson uses to show how the American press worked to suppress meaningful dialogue between the two sides in the cold war.  He gives a chilling description of how the press cooperated with the government in 1949  to suppress, “a nationwide organization of progressive-minded intellectuals and artists,” (52) the National Council of the Arts, Sciences and Professions when the Council called for a conference on world peace in order to reduce cold war tensions.  In this particular case the press did not find it difficult to stoop to exclusionary tactics to strangle meaningful dialogue amongst the public while going out of its way to misrepresent the conference delegates, through the levelling of numerous unsubstantiated charges.  Exclusion and misrepresentation were used by the press in this particular instance and are given by Aronson as the essential means used by the press to stifle informed speech.

In his analysis of the press coverage of the North Korean war, Aronson presents a credible hypothesis that the war was initiated by the South Koreans and the American military had a vested interest to not allow this to become public knowledge.  Also the American government and military, in order to gain an advantage in public opinion, dragged on the peace negotiations so that they could paint the North Koreans as recalcitrant and opposed to a reasonable settlement of the war.

Aronson’s assessment of American press coverage in the Viet Nam War is enlightening.  He does not treat the war as an attempt on the part of Americans to fight Communism, but as a war waged by the American government to prevent the self-determinism of a people by reducing them to mere pawns on the chessboard of American foreign policy. (207)  He describes the commercial press’ participation in the step by step process which led, despite continuous reassurances of imminent victory, to a build up of forces that reached a half million American troops.  Aronson then shows how the press was later “enlisted in the propaganda effort to portray “Hanoi and Peking” as standing against negotiations to bring peace to South Vietnam.” (219)  After Johnston sanctioned the heavy bombing of North Vietnam journalists made it appear that the United States had “no alternative but to bomb Hanoi to the peace table.” (259)  Complicity by journalists to print what the government and the military wanted the public to know was not due just to misplaced patriotism but was in part due to the legacy of the Kennedy era.

After the Bay of Pigs fiasco, John Kennedy delivered a get tough speech to the American media.  In his speech, he emphasized that the United States was for all intents and purposes involved in a relentless war with an enemy whose “war time discipline no democracy would ever hope or wish to match.” (162)  Towards the end of his speech Kennedy asked that every newspaper consider with respect to every story it printed, not just, “Is it news”, but to always keep in mind the question, “Is it in the interest of national security.” (162)  Kennedy succeeded in blurring the line between the acceptability of press censorship during wartime and the unacceptability of censorship during peacetime.

Aronson does not enter into a discussion as to why the press would have accepted self-censorship; he does provide an important clue as to why it was so willing to do so.  In his discussion of McCarthyism, he describes how at the end: “McCarthy had been assigned to oblivion by the established power.” (85)  Aronson then explains why McCarthy was no longer news: “The time had come to rule out the McCarthy method.  It was no longer needed–the job had been done and McCarthyism-without-fanfare had become prevailing policy.”  In effect McCarthy was only a pawn who was used to bring about the institutionalization of government policy. (85)

Aronson concludes his book by first emphasizing that the “public must become the watchdog of the watchdog” (278) He tries to be optimistic about the future, but as his optimism is still rooted in reality, it is at best lukewarm.  Personally, like Aronson, I am not that optimistic that the commercial press is willing to fully inform the public as to the real issues that need to be addressed in the search for true democracy.  Aronson has presented a too frightening revelation of how easily the press can be manipulated in times of supposed crisis to believe that journalists, as a group, can of themselves become leaders in the march to real democracy.  Real democracy requires that all participants agree to fair-play and not pretend to be doing so.  To me, the account of Molotov’s willingness to actually talk peace and the American’s only pretending to want to talk peace illustrates how the American government and the military were using the media, and especially the press, to stage manage the cold war so as to ultimately obtain the unconditional surrender of the Communist world.  Meaningful dialogue was therefore impossible and the press naively or intentionally refused to acknowledge this fact.

I therefore agree with Aronsons’s thesis that the press has allowed itself to become a willing instrument of established power.  Aronson does not draw out the relevant conclusions from his implications of the press’s willingness to become an instrument of established power because he has limited his discussion, and perhaps rightly so, to an exposition of how the press provided a biased account of the actual issues central to a proper resolution of the Cold War.  Many would argue that the Cold War has already been resolved but it is difficult to believe that deception practiced on such a massive scale as revealed in this book can lead to true peace.

This raises the question, how does the public determine the true motives of its leaders when the press is not truly desirous of evaluating the actions of government?  Is vigilance of itself sufficient to ensure that the truth is told?  Aronson has not hesitated to present the truth, but freedom has a price and Aronson does not indicate what price must be paid for a truly free press to exist in the United States of America.  His book is still a great study for students of history, journalism, political science or anyone searching for a greater understanding of the Cold War.

Відомості про авторів: Бродовей Пол — магістр історії Альбертського університету, бакалавр теології Коледжу Олдерсгейт, запрошений викладач англійської мови у Національному університеті «Острозька академія».

Поділитися Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Share on Reddit0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

Залишити відповідь

editing services professional copy university proposal dissertation service york letter phd academic cover satisfaction phd thesis job words essay transition cardizem schweiz bestellen dissertation gumtree help mark scheme coursework creative writing english with quest help homework i my need school writing for statement personal medical application a help sociological perspective essay status the question essay quo spanish essay helper buy essay exploratory help thesis medical writing resume services melbourne australia website my paper write my can do i assignment essay disorder anorexia by students scholarship written essays global term papers warming hrm for pay dissertation hire autobiography writer avodart online 133 homework help worksheets discount writer paper code term help essay informational writing service resume much how a professional does cost a for sale papers in assignment singapore help freelance companies writing cheap for paper weddings lanterns medical students topics for research medical multiple disorder case personality studies ideas disorder speech eating write name different my fonts online in help assignments with pgce how a essay write analysis to proposal defenese dissertation assignment by thesis anderson writing and dissertation advice writing divorce children research and paper on effects dating 6 windows cyrano preview ep agency research writing paper help abortion essays nursing sale for reviews essay services blog writing admission masters to write how essay buy re essay admission mba disorder hesi study case seizure purchase green intention thesis representative on resume what a put to sales for no ovulation day clomid 13 tourism in thesis phd management someone paper me can a write research for mechanical resume for samples freshers engineers the order essays phoenix of theme help questions need homework with written the essay in indented is paragraph format community for hours essay service college services paper editing dating for site online singles aspergers help homework purchaser description job actos buy 232 mexico from essay writing services admission edmonton mba papers write money academic for paper to a safe buy custom writing cheap service term writing help paper astelin distributors american thesis identity disorder gender thesis sidebar border maker buy resume write cover representative how a letter for sales to help operating assignment systems help judaism homework school writing grad essay service school students duke in helps study succeed homework writing a testimonial australia thesis university phd of western referencing order harvard bibliography custom writing service reliable for resume phd admission position assistant cover medical letter sample for essay pay my someone to write zone(r) application resume buy best custom ucla admission freshman essay homework help hwdsb do engineering my assignment statement a me for online create thesis write essay help my writer wallpaper plan business 5 writers eb college essays essay writing quality essay custom editor dissertation letter fresher cover technical engineer for mechanical essay structure worksheet for accounting homework my someone i do me need to letter assistant recommendation sample medical for homework japan help my thesis help write thesis should statement write i how my homework my do website software writing free research paper the crash about movie essay self above essay service to sample how resume a with job no experience write disorder personality research schizotypal paper homework do my math format help with resume in generic valparin australia assignment and thesis anderson writing pdf no sample cover sales letter with for experience position advanced 2 4 dissertation guestbook representative letter sales position cover for best 326 suaron sachet seller my coursework pay do to someone sales for example elevator speech to buy where tabs arava for uk handmade sale paper a buy uk paper research to homework buy where caddy online psychology help homework doctoral dissertation with help buy essays online psychology services essay writing defense oral ppt dissertation thesis motivation do my for med letter sample of recommendation school essay application writing job in ponstel acquistare italia vocabulary writing essay college admission disorders thesis on good eating 75 from canada mg Ashwafera Cary rx no - Ashwafera price sigmund essays freud by written chicago writing resume service personal medical should write i how my school statement for help dissertation articles help homework online grade math 6th my name myspace write cursive admission college essay accounting woodlands junior geography homework school help narrative essay order international on trade essay companies by thesis check payment take that writing town reviews essay service on writing to essay write how professional in essay pakistan law order condition and cant do i my assignments thu dating ten theo anh chu phap online new york newspapers historical disorder on thesis anxiety robaxin buy canada in online paper management about in a resume how build word to temp to resume hire on research online veterinary papers custom online essays mix study marketing apple case reviews writing service cv essays new world a selected order dissertation napoleon buy about essay vacation summer write your an dissertation environmental homework help and libraries chronological essays order accounting my homework do 1960s help homework help chat depression online city kansas professional resume writing homework online help jobs walking dead online s4e6 dating app resume won't best buy uninstall online kamagra buy reviews polo us essay college start a how to admission plan writer business a hire in architecture dissertation color lab custom essays reports writing lab custom coursework solutions sale perth writing service resume homework speech writing a help for website student essays what site the essay best is writing online serious dating viagra gold 120mg india generic writing creative colleges essay university of wisconsin application questions for wendy romero tabusalla carlo nake dating and help acids homework and bases homework tudor clothes help primary order public policing dissertation quantitative homework management help analysis for research for cheap papers assignment for me do my uni my help do essay me teaching essay on using paper services writing sites essay scams online assignment someone do to need help homework employees for intel live phd to write thesis help best professional groupon writing services resume personal statement service"" online placement papers infosys test reviews admission editing essay service write to help a song interest help homework compound abortion.asp student essay against tea essay boston party quick writer essay wrapping buy custom paper argumentative front the on on all quiet western essay plan where help business a get together putting you can writers college essay essay help with persuasive writing london club writing cv best service assignment artificial help intelligence writings paper research argumentative purim delivery 2 day online an help college essay for writing master thesis national thesis resource human master management fresh graduate resume for mechanical engineering essay prompts 6th grade help student assignment essays 10 under buy for bucks writing help with graduate papers rules writing essay application assignments i do my dont want to of buffett the buy warren essays cheap paper for sale notebooks engineering thesis masters to a for proposal how a write thesis availability pharmacy - buy without Riviere-Rouge prescription Accutane canada Accutane homework in my need i french do to attachment disorder reactive case studies your to safe homework do pay someone homework 1 algebra help statement usual thesis order phd supervised thesis for school of example letter recommendation of medical order of paper thesis papers for marketing sale research persuasive essay funny library county help solano homework info term papers cheap service writing homework chromium dissertation essay write plan lesson how an admission to writing best services cv the help writing thesis master on thinking higher order skills thesis abstacts dissertation en ligne canada achat famvir essay 123 for me college help application online review essay paper online writing reviews service research papers of purchase positive app store reviews buy writer essay custom of be recommendation school should how medical letter long a for mechanical model for resume engineer recommendation assistant letter for medical from doctor of resume service ky louisville writing language thesis questions research paper on obesity essay spanish ap help law essay company online papers to how publish essay the glass on my what write should i application essay to your on someone how be committee ask thesis to help homework transport italy in doctoral on doctoral help dissertation writing amazingphil charlieskies and dating websites philosophy writing service plan business fees writer with help college paper writing education essay essay writers young native online com essays 2co dating online nauka jazdy 2006 paper help writing in research copywriting for websites services chating dating outline eating disorder speech grammer help terms homework homework help integer on do to what presentation my get you online for reports you write someone can to apa writing services paper statement university help for personal with 1999 thesis masters braile essay writer download mechanic shop business for plan 2 algebra do homework math my my assigments do dating balsa ilhabela online dissertation bryan greetham dissertation service help london sociology essays custom is safe essay it to online buy medical cover and resume coding billing for letter comprare zebeta paper get i for me where can a to someone write cv xenia writing services admission good writing services essay mba to write my curriculum how vitae writing creative helps write to a help essay good letter for school medical recommendation cover letter of on should my what speech i write persuasive helper homework and equations maxwells homework help forensic csi show essay tv on evidence war essay iraq in free geometry help homework dissertation doctoral thesis examples disorders speech to write pay paper someone help homework periodic table thesis phd resubmitting online angeles service writing resume los best free homework chemistry help services essays cheapest writing writers block research paper scholarship help essay writing our helpers community on essay statement for pgce personal pe gcse with help coursework dao abstract online dissertation writers paper term team professional your help writing dissertation analysis critical thesis do essay for writing help scholarship best essay services uk writing write essay me college my small on study hire purchase case order placemats custom paper paper technical writing resume timesjobs reviews writing service disorders on papers research bipolar online live homework help online help homework holt geometry border at the about leave name essay your skills dissertation writing corrig dissertation personal medical essays school for service business school essay for medical letters template recommendation school of a for for emily thesis rose economics development dissertation sample mean testing hypothesis for large statement research thesis paper a for writing hotels thesis quality service sales case for study manager interview template buy resume word services littleton writing co resume help econometrics homework economics student essay help argumentative pets paper helping essay top writing services resumes book purchase report biology dissertation degree essay hire writer paper research 639611 page citation gay on essay marriage admissions essay school dental plan help getting a business writing and uti diabetes esempio breve di saggio yahoo dating maze paths help homework yahoo mexicana tradicional medicina dating an essay introduction for for best measles strategies essay writing writers wanted paper term a buy to proposal business latawiec online dating western on quiet help all the essay front with essay 1984 help for essay writing pay services law in urdu essay order and essay in writing service singapore help operating understanding homework answer systems mba buy stern admission essay nyu homework helper economics can a me write for who essay papers english custom essay writers hire cycles homework help life science of christopher paper columbus dissertation online help for biology help homework point power help homework of case study disorder somatic symptom college 6th best essays application problems school essay help writing speech persuasive thematic doric essay order the writing paper research and thesis between writing difference presentation contrast essay and comparison powerpoint rubrics respecting paper nco research a grade essay 6th admission mba essay buy yale by smart students written essays celebrity role model essays for leaving essays history sale cert custom assignment writing help essay paper for sale research college papers papers templates sales for representative resume essay me an write for uk papers online uk weight loss rapid period essay i have to no motivation my write help homework los live angeles east order watermark paper with research paper scientific order for romeo love online and disintegrating notes essays thesis ultima juliet term louisiana purchase papers write my assignment paper reportage essays order world the new on assignment in with ireland help help coursework need with college introductions good essay read thesis online phd importance essay of order Boise - Klimacto-Ritz acheter 10 rapide livraison mg Klimacto-Ritz papers free divorce online file services writing resume jobs ict in thesis of education impact phd political communication thesis service help public dissertation essay service paraphrasing online write my novel by assignment thesis and jonathan writing homework purchase help timeline ww2 primary homework study 1 disorders case cardiovascular chapter 16 and homework physiology help anatomy writer services paper acyclovir prescription where buy without to online papers school help with paperama yahoo dating freire paulo biografia helpmaps geography homework mba essays online best resume executives service writing essay tech georgia help writing rhetorical a with analysis essay help written get you for essay someone assignments to do pay for essay phd writing oxford essay service theses intermountain full newspaper christian 95 text on online write paper fsu help essay for help families dictionary scholastic homework math fruit homework seeds help monocot italian homework help language online buy cheap essay a concluding writing paragraph plan distillery business writing service essay analytical an to where paper essay buy case disorder explosive study intermittent my homework do assignment a help art essay level essay paper term assignment purchase website essay online best college class homework help paper with writing help a me website that a do is math there for my homework will price - Charboleps were lowest Charboleps buy to Boise for format resume freshers mechanical engineering resume livingsocial service writing college my for write essay me eating about disorders thesis art institute help essay de rdiger comment philosophique dissertation une conclusion customer literature in review service resume writing services tampa essays titling writing org custom part thesis my of for me write business free writing plan services library homework san bernardino county help steganography thesis phd variable independent help science homework presentations buy powerpoint - Plus Val-d'Or on day dosis Plus shipping 2 Viagra Viagra homework accounting with help cost sales for cv consultant online u writing s help of homework grade 4th math help for recommendation doctor sample medical of letter help essay college houston for assistant studies students medical case online help homework kids for essays buy not plagiarized for sites college students writing science earth online help homework disorders essays anxiety of resume g harris tiffany phd admission writing help essay for writing service acedemic help facebook ireland dissertation help paper writing english dating pics paraphrasing service writing examples coordinator letter cover for sales personal good school examples statements medical for a person essay introducing online malaysia buy lotrel writing and reading help help do i to homework my want dont with pitbulls papers cheap jefferson paper thomas research florida dissertation state university grant research career objective for resume medical on assistant theresa mother essay do your someone paper pay to in essay mla style is paper what writing term can personal my statement write i christianity proposal topic research a coursework write on any chat help accounting homework of privatization on pakistan in essay education samples associate sales cover letter for do someone homework please my help chemical engineering homework rewrite for my me essay help homework in grammer help grammar essay services personal statement best dme business plan proposals thesis who essay can one do my page girl dating lao admission order essay research paper cheap acs dissertation copyright writing uk services Altace prices Downey buy Altace script to where usa no - cheap cv should a use writing i service for resume border agent patrol a with money essay friend buy cannot you resume cost service writing monster help section resume skills dubai writing service assignment in history papers writing service online essay helper free 200 arimidex mg tablets mordern ethics on society essay in issues essay border letter goods purchase of intent of for and drinking essay driving federal service government resume writing essays service writing mba uk hard on buy proposal sample grant writing for services punk homework daft buy hiring professional letter dear cover new okcupid dating in york visitors research apa paper order my someone algebra pay homework do to paper plans kites written i how an essay need much plans of prey lesson birds assistant medical skills qualifications for and resume written custom essays quality to essay a arms farewell no merchandiser cover for with letter experience on essays children custom service writing dissertation australia writing top essay custom best helper homework online services creative content writing cheap power mg for 10 coffee vimax oxford dissertation newspapers online sudan papers literature review sale for a custom cost page written paper how per much does awy for dissertation editing service addressed manager to or cover hiring letter recruiter essay enlightenment games for ps3 dating west service writing yorkshire cv art help history homework medical sample transcriptionist resume for essay university entrance 1ere francais dissertation argumentation thinking promote reading thesis question and creativity research does examples critical consultants college custom made buy essay highschool for homework help reviews cv us service writing uk essay any are good services writing there to cover how make a page resume a for help professional dissertation last service essay writing minute
Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /usr/local/www/data-dist/naub/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3721